Skip to content

Conversation

@aniketdivekar
Copy link
Contributor

@aniketdivekar aniketdivekar commented Sep 19, 2025

Description

This PR implements a comprehensive validator whitelist system for the Shardeum EVM chain, providing governance-controlled validator consensus participation management. The implementation includes a full Cosmos SDK module with on-chain state management, governance proposals, and fail-fast transaction processing.

Key Features

  • On-chain Governance Module: Complete x/validatorwhitelist module with keeper, message server, query server, and genesis support
  • Governance Proposals: Three proposal types for runtime whitelist management:
    • MsgUpdateWhitelist: Enable/disable whitelist and update allowlist
    • MsgAddValidator: Add validators to the allowlist
    • MsgRemoveValidator: Remove validators from the allowlist
  • Fail-fast Transaction Processing: Zero gas consumption for blocked delegations to non-whitelisted validators
  • Comprehensive Testing: Full test suite covering types, keeper, interfaces, and integration scenarios
  • Production-ready Documentation: Complete runbook and technical documentation

Critical Files to Review

Core Module Implementation

  • x/validatorwhitelist/keeper/keeper.go - Core keeper with state management
  • x/validatorwhitelist/keeper/msg_server.go - Governance message handlers
  • x/validatorwhitelist/keeper/query_server.go - Query interface implementation
  • x/validatorwhitelist/types/params.go - Parameter validation and business logic

Integration & Ante Handler

  • ante/cosmos/validator_whitelist.go - Transaction decorator for fail-fast processing
  • ante/interfaces/validator_whitelist_keeper.go - Interface implementations for modularity
  • shardeumd/app.go - Module wiring and keeper initialization

Protobuf Definitions

  • proto/shardeum/validatorwhitelist/v1/tx.proto - Message definitions
  • proto/shardeum/validatorwhitelist/v1/query.proto - Query definitions
  • proto/shardeum/validatorwhitelist/v1/genesis.proto - Genesis state

Testing & Documentation

  • x/validatorwhitelist/types/*_test.go - Parameter and genesis validation tests
  • x/validatorwhitelist/keeper/*_test.go - Keeper functionality tests
  • ante/interfaces/validator_whitelist_keeper_test.go - Interface compliance tests
  • docs/validator_whitelist.md - Technical documentation
  • docs/validator_whitelist_runbook.md - End-to-end testing guide

Behavior Changes

  • Validator Creation: Non-whitelisted validators cannot create validator transactions (prevents self-delegation bypass)
  • Delegation Control: Delegations to non-whitelisted validators are blocked with zero gas consumption
  • Governance Integration: Whitelist management through standard Cosmos governance proposals
  • Runtime Configuration: Whitelist can be enabled/disabled and validators added/removed without chain restart

Testing

The implementation includes comprehensive test coverage:

  • Unit tests for all core functionality
  • Integration tests for end-to-end workflows
  • Interface compliance testing
  • Production scenario validation

Run tests with:

go test -v ./x/validatorwhitelist/...
go test -v ./ante/interfaces/

Documentation

Complete documentation is provided:

  • Technical specification in docs/validator_whitelist.md
  • End-to-end testing runbook in docs/validator_whitelist_runbook.md
  • Inline code documentation and examples

Author Checklist

All items are required. Please add a note to the item if the item is not applicable and
please add links to any relevant follow up issues.

I have...

  • tackled an existing issue or discussed with a team member
  • left instructions on how to review the changes
  • targeted the main branch

Review Instructions

  1. Start with the documentation (docs/validator_whitelist.md) to understand the system design
  2. Review the core module (x/validatorwhitelist/keeper/) for business logic implementation
  3. Check the ante handler (ante/cosmos/validator_whitelist.go) for transaction processing logic
  4. Validate the interface design (ante/interfaces/) for modularity and testability
  5. Run the test suite to ensure all functionality works as expected
  6. Follow the runbook (docs/validator_whitelist_runbook.md) for end-to-end validation

Key Design Decisions

  • Interface-based Architecture: Enables multiple keeper implementations (config-based, on-chain, mock)
  • Fail-fast Processing: Zero gas consumption for blocked transactions prevents resource waste
  • Governance Integration: Standard Cosmos governance proposals for runtime management
  • Comprehensive Testing: Full test coverage ensures reliability and maintainability

@aniketdivekar aniketdivekar changed the base branch from main to dev September 22, 2025 05:51
@mssabr01
Copy link
Contributor

do security review

@github-actions
Copy link

🔍 Security Review Report

❌ Failed to generate security review report. Please check the action logs for details.

You can also download the full output as an artifact if available.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

3 participants