Paper: THEIA: An Offline Tool for Tradespace Visualization

[samuelcwilliams]

If you are creating this PR in order to submit a draft of your paper, please name your PR with Paper: <title>. An editor will then add a paper label and GitHub Actions will be run to check and build your paper.

See the project readme for more information.

Editor: Hongsup Shin @hongsupshin

Reviewers:

• Mihai Maruseac @mihaimaruseac
• Suzana Serboi @ssuzana
• Tetsuo Koyama @tkoyama010

[github-actions]

Curvenote Preview

Directory	Preview	Checks	Updated (UTC)
papers/theia	🔍 Inspect	✅ 37 checks passed (7 optional)	Jul 22, 2024, 4:57 PM

[ameyxd]

@samuelcwilliams thanks for the submission! Can you add the DOI for plotly? We can run the checks again after.

you may be able to add citation keys you want to ignore if their DOIs don't exist in myst.yml under error_rules:

error_rules:
  - rule: doi-exists
    severity: ignore
    keys:
      - abc
      - def01

[samuelcwilliams]

@ameyxd, I followed Plotly citation guidance found here, and it didn't include a DOI, so I set it to ignore.

[ameyxd]

thanks @samuelcwilliams cheers.

[mihaimaruseac]

Overall, this looks good, but I think it would be even more useful if you can show how the data listed at the beginning of the paper is processed to produce the screenshots at the end. Does the user have to type code? If yes, can you include the code? If not, can you then show how this will work with a more complex data type?

[samuelcwilliams]

@mihaimaruseac I made some small changes and added in some new content regarding the data upload process and the details on the screenshots in the paper. Let me know if you think there are any areas I should expand on. I appreciate all the feedback!

[mihaimaruseac]

Thank you

[tkoyama010]

Thank you. The logic of this paper itself seems perfect to me. I just didn't quite understand background what Tradespace meant. I would like you to explain in more detail what kind of data you are trying to process.

[tkoyama010]

I'm sorry, I closed the PR by mistake.

[tkoyama010]

Thank you. The logic of this paper itself seems perfect to me. I just didn't quite understand background what Tradespace meant. I would like you to explain in more detail what kind of data you are trying to process.

@cbcunc I already finished review :)

[samuelcwilliams]

@tkoyama010, I added in some additional details on what tradespace data is. I tried to be concise, as I tend to ramble on sometimes. Let me know of any additional edits that come to mind!

[tkoyama010]

LGTM Thanks!

[hongsupshin]

Thanks @tkoyama010 @mihaimaruseac @ssuzana for reviewing the paper!