-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 3
HUT Data Issues
The map file contains 9 obsids not in the obscore file:
gd394_21101_a
gd394_06401_d
gd394_09201_d
gd394_34001_a
k1-16_27566
a2597----
n132d----
gam-gem----
gd394_13801_d
The gd394 links probably map to the following entries (note the sort/uniq call to remove the duplicate obsid values we see in the HUT obscore table):
% grep -i gd394 ../AstroExplorer/Missions/MAST/hut/obscore.hut.psv | awk -F \| '{ print $10 " " $13 " " $17; }' - | sort | uniq
GD394 gd394_064_01, GD394 gd394_064_01
GD394 gd394_092_01, GD394 gd394_092_01
GD394 gd394_092_02, GD394 gd394_092_02
GD394 gd394_092_03, GD394 gd394_092_03
GD394 gd394_138_01, GD394 gd394_138_01
GD394 gd394_138_02, GD394 gd394_138_02
GD394 gd394_211_01, GD394 gd394_211_01
GD394 gd394_211_02, GD394 gd394_211_02
GD394 gd394_340_01, GD394 gd394_340_01
GD394 gd394_340_02, GD394 gd394_340_02
The bibliography has:
% grep -i gd3 ../AstroExplorer/Missions/MAST/hut/map.hut.txt
1995ApJ...454L...1K gd394_064
1995ApJ...454L...1K gd394_092
1995ApJ...454L...1K gd394_138
1995ApJ...454L...1K gd394_211
1995ApJ...454L...1K gd394_340
2000ApJ...537..977D gd394_06401_d
2000ApJ...537..977D gd394_09201_d
2000ApJ...537..977D gd394_13801_d
2000ApJ...537..977D gd394_21101_a
2000ApJ...537..977D gd394_34001_a
2001MNRAS.328..211B gd394_092
2001MNRAS.328..211B gd394_138
2001MNRAS.328..211B gd394_211
So it looks like the 2000ApH...547..977D lines should have the trailing 01_[da] removed.
The gam-gem one from:
% cat ../AstroExplorer/Missions/MAST/hut/obscore.hut.psv | awk -F \| '{ print $10 " " $13 " " $17; }' - | sort | uniq | grep -i gem | grep -i gam
GAM-GEM gam-gem_126, GAM-GEM gam-gem_126
GAM-GEM gam-gem_128, GAM-GEM gam-gem_128
The bibliography has
% grep -i gam ../AstroExplorer/Missions/MAST/hut/map.hut.txt
1993Sci...259..327D gam-gem----
1993Sci...259..327D gam-gem_126
1993Sci...259..327D gam-gem_128
So we can probably ignore gam-gem----.
The k1-16 is likely:
% cat ../AstroExplorer/Missions/MAST/hut/obscore.hut.psv | awk -F \| '{ print $10 " " $13 " " $17; }' - | sort | uniq | grep -i k1
K1-16 k1-16_275_01, K1-16 k1-16_275_01
and the bibliography has:
% grep -i k1 ../AstroExplorer/Missions/MAST/hut/map.hut.txt
1998ApJ...502..858K k1-16_27566
The MAST results for 1998ApH...502..858K do not mention the K1-16 data set.
From the bibliography:
% grep -i 2597 ../AstroExplorer/Missions/MAST/hut/map.hut.txt
1993Sci...259..327D a2597----
and the MAST results for 1993Sci...259..327D shows a lot of data (as it's a mission-review type paper).
Aha, searching HUT for the target A2597 results in two matches:
http://archive.stsci.edu/cgi-bin/mastpreview?mission=hut&dataid=a2597---- http://archive.stsci.edu/cgi-bin/mastpreview?mission=hut&dataid=gn2ful15_130
with essentially the same meta data (the start times are the same, the split between day and night is slightly different). Note that the A2597 link above has no data, and that the other id does appear in both the map and obscore values:
% grep -i gn2ful15_130 ../AstroExplorer/Missions/MAST/hut/map.hut.txt
1993Sci...259..327D gn2ful15_130
and
% cat ../AstroExplorer/Missions/MAST/hut/obscore.hut.psv | awk -F \| '{ print $10 " " $13 " " $17; }' - | grep -i gn2ful15_130
GN2FUL15 gn2ful15_130, GN2FUL15 gn2ful15_130
GN2FUL15 gn2ful15_130, GN2FUL15 gn2ful15_130
GN2FUL15 gn2ful15_130, GN2FUL15 gn2ful15_130
GN2FUL15 gn2ful15_130, GN2FUL15 gn2ful15_130
GN2FUL15 gn2ful15_130, GN2FUL15 gn2ful15_130
GN2FUL15 gn2ful15_130, GN2FUL15 gn2ful15_130
Suggestion is to ignore the a2597 version.
This is for the same "review" paper as the missing a2597 value:
% grep -i n132 ../AstroExplorer/Missions/MAST/hut/map.hut.txt
1993Sci...259..327D n132d----
There's no obvious match to the obscore table here:
% cat ../AstroExplorer/Missions/MAST/hut/obscore.hut.psv | awk -F \| '{ print $10 " " $13 " " $17; }' - | grep -i 132
0242+132 0242p132_182_01, 0242+132 0242p132_182_01
M31 m31_132, M31 m31_132
M31 m31_132, M31 m31_132
M31 m31_132, M31 m31_132
M31 m31_132, M31 m31_132
M31 m31_132, M31 m31_132
M31 m31_132, M31 m31_132
NGC3132 ngc3132_294_01, NGC3132 ngc3132_294_01
NGC3132 ngc3132_294_01, NGC3132 ngc3132_294_01
NGC3132 ngc3132_294_02, NGC3132 ngc3132_294_02
NGC3132 ngc3132_294_02, NGC3132 ngc3132_294_02
NGC3132 ngc3132_294_02, NGC3132 ngc3132_294_02
NGC3132 ngc3132_294_02, NGC3132 ngc3132_294_02
NGC4449 ngc4449_132_01, NGC4449 ngc4449_132_01
NGC4449 ngc4449_132_01, NGC4449 ngc4449_132_01
NGC4449 ngc4449_132_01, NGC4449 ngc4449_132_01
NGC4449 ngc4449_132_01, NGC4449 ngc4449_132_01
NGC4449 ngc4449_132_01, NGC4449 ngc4449_132_01
NGC4449 ngc4449_132_01, NGC4449 ngc4449_132_01
V1329CYG v1329cyg_153_01, V1329CYG v1329cyg_153_01
V1329CYG v1329cyg_153_01, V1329CYG v1329cyg_153_01