Add auto route classifier (#323)

* Add auto route classifier * Add some german and spanish APIs * french apis * Integration test * Benchmarks * Improve performance * Update name * Happy linter * Don't make heuristic default * Add warning message * Add docs * Update integration test --------- Co-authored-by: Mario Macias <[email protected]>
grafana · Oct 4, 2023 · 88f34f5 · 88f34f5
1 parent 173401b
commit 88f34f5
Show file tree

Hide file tree

Showing 22 changed files with 757 additions and 2 deletions.
diff --git a/docs/sources/configure/_index.md b/docs/sources/configure/_index.md
@@ -20,3 +20,8 @@ Beyla can be configured in the following ways:
 For information on the metrics Beyla exports, see the [exported metrics]({{< relref "../metrics.md" >}}) documentation.
 
 For information on profiling Beyla, see the [profiling]({{< relref "../profiling.md" >}}) documentation.
+
+**Note**: If you will be using Beyla to generate traces, please make sure you've read our documentation section on configuring 
+the [Routes Decorator]({{< relref "../configure/options#routes-decorator" >}}). Since Beyla is auto-instrumenting your application without any
+special language level support, configuring the low cardinality routes decorator is very important for optimal results.
+
diff --git a/docs/sources/configure/options.md b/docs/sources/configure/options.md
@@ -216,6 +216,32 @@ Possible values for the `unmatch` property are:
 - `path` will copy the `http.route` field property to the path value.
   - 🚨 Caution: this option could lead to cardinality explosion at the ingester side.
 - `wildcard` will set the `http.route` field property to a generic asterisk based `/**` value.
+- `heuristic` will automatically derive the `http.route` field property from the path value, based on the following rules:
+  - Any path components which have numbers or characters outside of the ASCII alphabet (or `-` and `_`), will be replaced by an asterisk `*`.
+  - Any alphabetical components which don't look like words, will be replaced by an asterisk `*`.
+
+### Special considerations when using the `heuristic` route decorator mode
+
+The `heuristic` decorator is a best effort route decorator, which may still lead to cardinality explosion in certain scenarios.
+For example, the GitHub URL paths are a good example where the `heuristic` route decorator will not work, since the URL paths
+are constructed like a directory tree. In this scenario all paths will remain unique and lead to cardinality explosion.
+
+On the other hand, if your URL path patterns follow certain structure, and the unique IDs are made up of numbers or random characters,
+then the `heuristic` decorator may be a low effort configuration option which is suitable for your use-case. For example, the following
+mock Google Docs URLs will be correctly reduced to a low cardinality version:
+
+Both URL paths below:
+
+```
+document/d/CfMkAGbE_aivhFydEpaRafPuGWbmHfG/edit (no numbers in the ID)
+document/d/C2fMkAGb3E_aivhFyd5EpaRafP123uGWbmHfG/edit
+```
+
+will be converted to a low cardinality route:
+
+```
+document/d/*/edit
+```
 
 ## OTEL metrics exporter
 

diff --git a/docs/sources/setup/_index.md b/docs/sources/setup/_index.md
@@ -19,3 +19,7 @@ There are different options to set up and run Beyla:
 3. [As a Kubernetes sidecar container]({{< relref "./kubernetes.md" >}})
 
 For information on configuration options and data export modes, see the [Configure Beyla]({{< relref "../configure/_index.md" >}}) documentation.
+
+**Note**: If you will be using Beyla to generate traces, please make sure you've read our documentation section on configuring 
+the [Routes Decorator]({{< relref "../configure/options#routes-decorator" >}}). Since Beyla is auto-instrumenting your application without any
+special language level support, configuring the low cardinality routes decorator is very important for optimal results.
diff --git a/go.mod b/go.mod
@@ -44,6 +44,7 @@ require (
 )
 
 require (
+	github.com/AlessandroPomponio/go-gibberish v0.0.0-20191004143433-a2d4156f0396 // indirect
 	github.com/beorn7/perks v1.0.1 // indirect
 	github.com/bytedance/sonic v1.9.1 // indirect
 	github.com/cenkalti/backoff/v4 v4.2.1 // indirect

diff --git a/go.sum b/go.sum
@@ -1,4 +1,6 @@
 cloud.google.com/go v0.26.0/go.mod h1:aQUYkXzVsufM+DwF1aE+0xfcU+56JwCaLick0ClmMTw=
+github.com/AlessandroPomponio/go-gibberish v0.0.0-20191004143433-a2d4156f0396 h1:cKIHT8I2mrmw/VgdyNeACP/AvetK8AgGsiRfOC3ZjmQ=
+github.com/AlessandroPomponio/go-gibberish v0.0.0-20191004143433-a2d4156f0396/go.mod h1:2VCDG9kHYQ5vfYUqeoB7foVlcvIvB7rp9LxTELLD1qU=
 github.com/BurntSushi/toml v0.3.1/go.mod h1:xHWCNGjB5oqiDr8zfno3MHue2Ht5sIBksp03qcyfWMU=
 github.com/armon/go-socks5 v0.0.0-20160902184237-e75332964ef5 h1:0CwZNZbxp69SHPdPJAN/hZIm0C4OItdklCFmMRWYpio=
 github.com/armon/go-socks5 v0.0.0-20160902184237-e75332964ef5/go.mod h1:wHh0iHkYZB8zMSxRWpUBQtwG5a7fFgvEO+odwuTv2gs=

diff --git a/pkg/internal/pipe/instrumenter_test.go b/pkg/internal/pipe/instrumenter_test.go
@@ -133,7 +133,7 @@ func TestRouteConsolidation(t *testing.T) {
 		return func(out chan<- []request.Span) {
 			out <- newRequest("svc-1", 1, "GET", "/user/1234", "1.1.1.1:3456", 200)
 			out <- newRequest("svc-1", 2, "GET", "/products/3210/push", "1.1.1.1:3456", 200)
-			out <- newRequest("svc-1", 3, "GET", "/attach", "1.1.1.1:3456", 200) // undefined route: won't report as route
+			out <- newRequest("svc-1", 3, "GET", "/attach", "1.1.1.1:3456", 200)
 			// closing prematurely the input node would finish the whole graph processing
 			// and OTEL exporters could be closed, so we wait.
 			time.Sleep(testTimeout)

diff --git a/pkg/internal/transform/route/classifier.json b/pkg/internal/transform/route/classifier.json
@@ -0,0 +1 @@
+{"Occurrences":[[-8.569137312930899,-3.9369332597631863,-3.220670162697391,-3.0482479869676102,-6.052279063336297,-4.69956099775001,-3.9941585968087816,-6.710407217596661,-3.2453041060602184,-7.060740255010108,-4.512283359624297,-2.4997201529644935,-3.642636781640966,-1.5707462805725019,-7.978468801653891,-3.8936418102220776,-9.821900281426267,-2.3025283782801376,-2.348366425382398,-1.9448651421947813,-4.539158126663701,-3.871849760115083,-4.706359120463831,-6.560313338465017,-3.649725323207633,-6.641954302926283,-2.7134701747591117],[-2.5528619980785,-5.139226208055755,-6.049719822245583,-6.219404795035026,-1.173596307609444,-8.563954087128105,-8.805116143944993,-8.494961215641153,-3.3328454702735173,-5.004532700251055,-8.805116143944993,-2.1390850632227165,-6.121607051758899,-6.808562262070924,-2.1459387811703974,-8.312639658847198,-8.900426323749317,-2.719375008855968,-3.788438535392774,-4.703224376087508,-2.137350056136624,-6.320209494156992,-7.676650892127201,-8.900426323749317,-2.3611294272462486,-8.900426323749317,-4.738423113053401],[-2.08946313988477,-9.398284978640158,-3.8466182187208457,-7.678499009037193,-1.7391136109740999,-8.792149175069843,-9.580606535434113,-1.9093388132314668,-2.9331775988939013,-9.485296355629789,-3.343650033348159,-3.276523430584318,-8.515895798441685,-8.838669190704735,-1.6000355228278762,-9.485296355629789,-6.386023403134956,-3.377666241879603,-5.838186314392146,-2.390910634629309,-3.2184408726543063,-9.485296355629789,-8.838669190704735,-9.580606535434113,-4.621264535725407,-8.299672689972049,-3.8668737299247438],[-3.7200475908408235,-7.418434550575756,-7.88681348409449,-4.564865474086475,-1.9699465394791131,-6.796896902393934,-5.430448837645974,-6.754155354016663,-2.4627220077183942,-6.277375571660389,-7.666270714480338,-4.558326450319418,-5.5188785108919935,-5.946484744877372,-3.117009722931763,-8.380471304238116,-8.136274343726074,-3.6243165394601604,-3.6811521539816408,-7.1936663035345445,-3.994198378682783,-5.568764165402863,-7.077327311450395,-9.928033812954128,-4.613843097249801,-9.745712256160173,-0.5394468422260206],[-3.0956911156796725,-6.3279563530093395,-3.711394117529345,-2.414309096615009,-3.7280101535107066,-4.555095809949321,-4.9582369569836615,-6.340824177620733,-4.465115884463944,-8.043262266521952,-7.012917948982845,-3.4395652463282116,-3.7489856294972617,-2.389153595060143,-5.281198278652138,-4.426598784036354,-6.265131628349503,-1.976271246918681,-2.519225987547763,-3.7331106440131854,-6.05129367580717,-4.115226028040922,-4.719249301196115,-4.451178867151557,-4.535588241035776,-7.731754615658102,-1.1291364595675442],[-2.7634422911455703,-7.9114774546442685,-7.529542843946299,-8.494623739989885,-2.451100566435661,-2.926120215794328,-7.612234559791412,-8.53718335440868,-2.4505074466080714,-9.033620240722573,-8.72823859117139,-3.748243385450271,-8.839464226281615,-7.66534438510536,-1.9043799278633868,-8.305381740351358,-9.370092477343785,-2.3558173549839756,-5.929674382528349,-3.315653131074415,-3.5058932812816797,-9.370092477343785,-7.801476559429941,-9.370092477343785,-6.135343303319295,-9.370092477343785,-0.9976707550554196],[-2.681117318742622,-8.560252680876685,-8.083328608786376,-6.8862762473050125,-1.9631827738890724,-7.924263914156688,-4.61975020412667,-2.2213641819441556,-2.8612966495974126,-9.148039345778804,-8.560252680876685,-3.35807917488155,-6.075346031088684,-3.7399711152716475,-2.831958278425978,-7.954116877306369,-9.052729165974478,-2.5526687518888194,-4.062915199691808,-4.943346726387837,-3.494498087559349,-9.148039345778804,-7.579423427864958,-9.148039345778804,-5.882279935011752,-8.617411094716633,-1.0302198528344138],[-1.8949866865832032,-7.38720654177459,-8.05310407988716,-7.542278456121169,-0.7286353651447546,-7.858315754328075,-9.589971299486425,-8.779041083270096,-1.9951372153459488,-10.100796923252416,-7.885223207247999,-6.635061020452689,-6.261344610659105,-6.705170586639715,-2.5617698674284206,-9.253499062865211,-10.100796923252416,-4.5720294302077304,-6.222675469499951,-3.7645613367085256,-4.622243506401445,-9.541181135316993,-7.3816968859636205,-10.28311848004637,-5.024581983510178,-10.187808300242045,-2.36230880075777],[-3.712244886548001,-4.717475282130211,-2.783984370515817,-3.2216013768067646,-3.1683365236496233,-3.9038254558612397,-3.680790547058952,-9.119304544100272,-6.422989599216483,-10.323277348426208,-5.240838322200969,-3.0795261367137394,-3.173687619686372,-1.3126793991869439,-2.664381175855551,-4.9236074876178835,-7.895529112478156,-3.409705684122631,-2.051579832828198,-2.1011937452905483,-6.511074678280273,-3.816746183294981,-9.672689782285058,-6.168308164387673,-10.410288725415837,-5.511770729440288,-3.788398987959084],[-2.3427609160575655,-6.1024094410597085,-6.037870919922137,-6.507874549167873,-1.4153520955994334,-6.245510284700382,-6.17140231254666,-6.325552992373918,-5.51462277615759,-6.507874549167873,-6.245510284700382,-6.412564369363548,-6.325552992373918,-6.507874549167873,-1.2783714986201964,-6.412564369363548,-6.325552992373918,-6.1024094410597085,-6.1024094410597085,-6.245510284700382,-1.1002544477293865,-6.507874549167873,-6.245510284700382,-6.507874549167873,-6.507874549167873,-6.507874549167873,-4.859215923580492],[-3.6194933584945135,-7.047703539402737,-6.062419936041631,-7.671857848475732,-1.2114318817004575,-6.285563487355841,-6.824559988088527,-3.6311485020862624,-1.7851984157338756,-7.814958692116405,-7.489536291681777,-3.88766821455747,-6.036102627724257,-2.3543916630889337,-3.8417682258102714,-7.546694705521725,-7.9820127767795706,-5.48206824962703,-3.0008999219496366,-6.6910285954640045,-3.73872587983735,-7.2444138336487915,-5.438265626968637,-8.077322956583895,-4.682814563072537,-8.077322956583895,-1.4288566755523215],[-2.269183388314388,-6.573297799694782,-5.745479365449931,-2.8596367214634224,-1.7841347050080587,-4.144047900909572,-6.844091654118041,-7.7437746495925355,-2.175115871017978,-9.701519256294851,-4.956587127931601,-2.065933606191924,-5.060338632783727,-6.492693767280152,-2.4508837443961715,-5.604400767190025,-9.701519256294851,-5.648286082315182,-3.879460040714278,-3.864517937852428,-3.820986269894151,-5.091361528795721,-5.466205750947557,-9.883840813088806,-2.3336002683489516,-8.602906967626742,-2.0434097729831913],[-1.7539942375247688,-3.6841198980845076,-6.559311098803656,-8.439623965373157,-1.3654444296574595,-6.4075846625879045,-9.337565558579115,-8.238953269911006,-2.4389427631602505,-9.17051147391595,-8.902247487321269,-6.206031743866062,-3.641082386404525,-5.662416297277081,-2.2280575251437695,-2.6972144960398214,-9.432875738383439,-5.501050105659114,-3.5381974599631496,-6.907147094075184,-3.4685254837670296,-9.250554181589486,-8.071899185247839,-9.432875738383439,-3.424799925470261,-9.432875738383439,-1.8968318511898539],[-3.41157713428474,-6.728285208389976,-3.0909427430720093,-1.740264825689735,-2.5015190512398306,-4.817371901371758,-2.113210530516431,-6.807749379744223,-3.295792549094097,-6.252798951069294,-4.917797884336954,-4.632769841879079,-5.98877585293416,-4.66665175664129,-2.876759518067293,-7.603753945743875,-6.864465609186075,-7.187239001449126,-3.052336215755031,-2.2647479268985964,-4.9001580949910455,-5.348959516586179,-7.14773655847288,-7.454376544669275,-4.546351845156791,-8.807726750069811,-1.4656789800236865],[-5.082241389138844,-5.142393631993602,-4.276598353328924,-4.085216817689867,-5.7599683850109145,-2.174773615995364,-5.288621572218711,-6.090174110360315,-4.4715723308194235,-6.90687468303798,-4.432658655412265,-3.2277431063139637,-2.8212923556513845,-1.7681088393713913,-3.5156224239092224,-3.9518016568316168,-8.986316224717816,-2.1664590794141954,-3.3712131841519417,-3.1224483347145418,-2.2101893882141153,-3.5450716407123704,-3.140479750467313,-6.663111844521034,-5.51344438505264,-7.704225641127928,-2.2129736790077486],[-2.136265349667144,-7.648749930275526,-6.522163789565011,-8.503165258431594,-1.734614577170007,-6.50168525822147,-7.785325465281278,-3.642577960578998,-2.654272848600284,-8.454375094262163,-7.8613113722592,-2.3851781986138283,-6.363099094935324,-7.294204912594619,-2.116201767527298,-2.7907534570773387,-9.196312438991539,-1.7868731941606955,-3.848728831140585,-3.2942257030347744,-3.1971277688684197,-9.196312438991539,-7.0800569241889875,-9.196312438991539,-4.987152202340858,-9.196312438991539,-2.9363486388485507],[-6.182291496945648,-6.182291496945648,-6.182291496945648,-6.182291496945648,-6.182291496945648,-6.182291496945648,-6.182291496945648,-6.182291496945648,-6.182291496945648,-6.182291496945648,-6.182291496945648,-6.182291496945648,-6.182291496945648,-6.182291496945648,-6.182291496945648,-6.182291496945648,-6.182291496945648,-6.182291496945648,-6.182291496945648,-6.182291496945648,-0.057170565024993084,-6.182291496945648,-6.182291496945648,-6.182291496945648,-6.182291496945648,-6.182291496945648,-5.540437610773254],[-2.5722807952437394,-5.99205725679638,-4.319316764551239,-3.7284294070555273,-1.4225483817556492,-5.357231686671419,-4.331760927128789,-6.033757985995324,-2.364541745819138,-9.405183209323809,-4.850464566831816,-4.673556599383159,-3.74500437214974,-3.916576116332641,-2.322164557359624,-5.413979406021222,-9.0405400957359,-3.636862213530037,-2.9016138569514562,-3.2345687965875074,-3.9816438780223904,-4.905818082232694,-6.257588586460572,-10.13915238440401,-3.258597025348527,-8.070182142591468,-1.7281348556024394],[-3.2090119684802527,-6.334899523154303,-4.093299064417374,-7.59203503906228,-2.1586345703035548,-6.182995193953419,-7.849503332917564,-2.915257814589145,-2.7754710419906368,-9.550291023939893,-4.551024457450397,-4.707131510786311,-4.589272322367449,-6.243245073400844,-2.9689285157149676,-3.853927304671137,-7.00903143760076,-8.243133983378726,-2.8108514947509753,-2.1177557637833035,-3.256550330868065,-7.865503674264006,-5.380597024476005,-10.383200146874996,-5.201416596582911,-9.913196517629261,-0.9911300598753203],[-3.1682706209020797,-8.217706195099385,-5.878899838671022,-9.525219678366163,-2.3388918749787213,-7.172402459885784,-8.478432457562638,-1.1074718716074006,-2.3662341497302157,-10.456777882371107,-9.689522729657439,-4.418539855249544,-6.032391973858083,-7.21960886445558,-2.3367153961191565,-8.16191483547097,-10.719142146838596,-3.4624215669877803,-3.6797447588047447,-4.0251990917417855,-3.9002180815630756,-9.555991337032916,-5.18259559155831,-10.131355481936478,-4.204725796166784,-7.984774637419013,-1.5835253210583506],[-3.6907063474960813,-3.7341336409281,-3.2454721262149633,-4.020608712629846,-3.281297978688059,-5.0172437658127595,-3.1933271849501734,-7.7963898885987,-3.73111886626001,-9.35453450664525,-6.208229374611885,-2.257675168572427,-3.4112977818505237,-2.089862646254399,-6.096437968623768,-3.100705695069777,-8.949069398537086,-1.905375903432984,-1.9722545836234537,-1.9648676140617645,-9.274491798971713,-6.7831953510849425,-9.35453450664525,-7.31765257938421,-7.3735330377786665,-5.267158613739243,-3.2700350935700784],[-2.4677551327310105,-8.46601472297182,-8.561324902776146,-7.868177722216201,-0.5192363285514866,-8.561324902776146,-8.298960638308655,-8.46601472297182,-1.7429474349452256,-8.46601472297182,-7.919471016603751,-5.443374996497906,-8.561324902776146,-4.566800675836256,-2.7892609207035393,-8.561324902776146,-8.561324902776146,-6.268790145635601,-4.407140340198028,-7.973538237874027,-6.289199017266808,-8.379003345982191,-8.030696651713976,-8.46601472297182,-5.258107929474194,-8.561324902776146,-3.1228109057348257],[-1.596798460957614,-7.6001421705956735,-7.640964165115928,-5.344648685135478,-1.8921021056868312,-6.839336341561913,-8.110967794361665,-1.6228272590921338,-1.7628783045649916,-8.87310784640856,-7.001305669506969,-5.467159861987808,-8.179960665848615,-3.2183655671770013,-2.524218636471301,-8.293289351155618,-9.209580083029774,-4.57000847032435,-4.2425484264156506,-5.65423202154036,-7.560921457442392,-9.209580083029774,-7.307472556632853,-9.209580083029774,-6.877436187794184,-9.02725852623582,-2.172728230713227],[-2.254780968033424,-6.898209866138606,-2.027603216646053,-6.492744758030441,-2.462642464536694,-5.833499129146177,-6.898209866138606,-4.310445830910898,-2.0731012597852527,-6.898209866138606,-6.898209866138606,-6.42820623689287,-6.715888309344651,-6.898209866138606,-4.4558628307694015,-1.4955324842663262,-6.3675816150764355,-4.636446767664815,-5.766807754647505,-1.8703897472882491,-4.37248122183035,-4.348764695213034,-6.802899686334281,-4.473407140420311,-5.175443268397502,-6.898209866138606,-2.5557039896270073],[-3.872874353532438,-6.07983833755968,-5.605956228985375,-6.1495716755743555,-2.9181087352006836,-5.833140189836589,-6.998723104610883,-7.317176835729417,-3.8266394412494407,-8.857621876676566,-7.45070822835394,-4.745382824577915,-4.447858487031085,-5.448125692199715,-2.2255103117197566,-4.737230605516364,-9.03994343347052,-5.751541545953709,-3.132676045163294,-4.230201081753655,-7.038463433260397,-7.65364907235063,-6.230540738108023,-7.70494236673818,-8.16447469611662,-7.731610613820342,-0.3817890191036424],[-2.531179599331457,-6.00314605188182,-5.907835872077495,-4.694813232231641,-0.9292230185496455,-5.907835872077495,-6.00314605188182,-3.199785670975285,-2.3395844057521735,-6.00314605188182,-5.666673815260607,-3.8868905370792675,-4.0016660516716955,-5.009894278871537,-1.7362497244615698,-6.00314605188182,-6.00314605188182,-6.00314605188182,-5.820824495087865,-5.907835872077495,-3.118345339035111,-5.666673815260607,-5.907835872077495,-6.00314605188182,-4.568061526592498,-3.7731316517226094,-3.1699327078256037],[-2.154456318300654,-3.132028909232904,-3.2042402732214343,-3.554775966080049,-3.8320798875631166,-3.2625149066892174,-4.1318426237305275,-2.7847122791384975,-2.7534204117779435,-5.68607428491371,-5.271518205104294,-3.779792629468334,-3.3524684982622075,-3.8123859357235683,-2.644532475328425,-3.3676057306367433,-6.237872536056438,-3.6809218434868227,-2.7030074975159986,-1.86142386740762,-4.4723885304095425,-4.918696830481552,-2.8042850405884527,-7.783949528282384,-4.702039558487341,-8.486442571260568,-3.2910629924454486]],"Positions":{"100":3,"101":4,"102":5,"103":6,"104":7,"105":8,"106":9,"107":10,"108":11,"109":12,"110":13,"111":14,"112":15,"113":16,"114":17,"115":18,"116":19,"117":20,"118":21,"119":22,"120":23,"121":24,"122":25,"32":26,"97":0,"98":1,"99":2},"Threshold":0.018782003473122023}
Original file line number	Diff line number	Diff line change
		@@ -0,0 +1 @@
		{"Occurrences":[[-8.569137312930899,-3.9369332597631863,-3.220670162697391,-3.0482479869676102,-6.052279063336297,-4.69956099775001,-3.9941585968087816,-6.710407217596661,-3.2453041060602184,-7.060740255010108,-4.512283359624297,-2.4997201529644935,-3.642636781640966,-1.5707462805725019,-7.978468801653891,-3.8936418102220776,-9.821900281426267,-2.3025283782801376,-2.348366425382398,-1.9448651421947813,-4.539158126663701,-3.871849760115083,-4.706359120463831,-6.560313338465017,-3.649725323207633,-6.641954302926283,-2.7134701747591117],[-2.5528619980785,-5.139226208055755,-6.049719822245583,-6.219404795035026,-1.173596307609444,-8.563954087128105,-8.805116143944993,-8.494961215641153,-3.3328454702735173,-5.004532700251055,-8.805116143944993,-2.1390850632227165,-6.121607051758899,-6.808562262070924,-2.1459387811703974,-8.312639658847198,-8.900426323749317,-2.719375008855968,-3.788438535392774,-4.703224376087508,-2.137350056136624,-6.320209494156992,-7.676650892127201,-8.900426323749317,-2.3611294272462486,-8.900426323749317,-4.738423113053401],[-2.08946313988477,-9.398284978640158,-3.8466182187208457,-7.678499009037193,-1.7391136109740999,-8.792149175069843,-9.580606535434113,-1.9093388132314668,-2.9331775988939013,-9.485296355629789,-3.343650033348159,-3.276523430584318,-8.515895798441685,-8.838669190704735,-1.6000355228278762,-9.485296355629789,-6.386023403134956,-3.377666241879603,-5.838186314392146,-2.390910634629309,-3.2184408726543063,-9.485296355629789,-8.838669190704735,-9.580606535434113,-4.621264535725407,-8.299672689972049,-3.8668737299247438],[-3.7200475908408235,-7.418434550575756,-7.88681348409449,-4.564865474086475,-1.9699465394791131,-6.796896902393934,-5.430448837645974,-6.754155354016663,-2.4627220077183942,-6.277375571660389,-7.666270714480338,-4.558326450319418,-5.5188785108919935,-5.946484744877372,-3.117009722931763,-8.380471304238116,-8.136274343726074,-3.6243165394601604,-3.6811521539816408,-7.1936663035345445,-3.994198378682783,-5.568764165402863,-7.077327311450395,-9.928033812954128,-4.613843097249801,-9.745712256160173,-0.5394468422260206],[-3.0956911156796725,-6.3279563530093395,-3.711394117529345,-2.414309096615009,-3.7280101535107066,-4.555095809949321,-4.9582369569836615,-6.340824177620733,-4.465115884463944,-8.043262266521952,-7.012917948982845,-3.4395652463282116,-3.7489856294972617,-2.389153595060143,-5.281198278652138,-4.426598784036354,-6.265131628349503,-1.976271246918681,-2.519225987547763,-3.7331106440131854,-6.05129367580717,-4.115226028040922,-4.719249301196115,-4.451178867151557,-4.535588241035776,-7.731754615658102,-1.1291364595675442],[-2.7634422911455703,-7.9114774546442685,-7.529542843946299,-8.494623739989885,-2.451100566435661,-2.926120215794328,-7.612234559791412,-8.53718335440868,-2.4505074466080714,-9.033620240722573,-8.72823859117139,-3.748243385450271,-8.839464226281615,-7.66534438510536,-1.9043799278633868,-8.305381740351358,-9.370092477343785,-2.3558173549839756,-5.929674382528349,-3.315653131074415,-3.5058932812816797,-9.370092477343785,-7.801476559429941,-9.370092477343785,-6.135343303319295,-9.370092477343785,-0.9976707550554196],[-2.681117318742622,-8.560252680876685,-8.083328608786376,-6.8862762473050125,-1.9631827738890724,-7.924263914156688,-4.61975020412667,-2.2213641819441556,-2.8612966495974126,-9.148039345778804,-8.560252680876685,-3.35807917488155,-6.075346031088684,-3.7399711152716475,-2.831958278425978,-7.954116877306369,-9.052729165974478,-2.5526687518888194,-4.062915199691808,-4.943346726387837,-3.494498087559349,-9.148039345778804,-7.579423427864958,-9.148039345778804,-5.882279935011752,-8.617411094716633,-1.0302198528344138],[-1.8949866865832032,-7.38720654177459,-8.05310407988716,-7.542278456121169,-0.7286353651447546,-7.858315754328075,-9.589971299486425,-8.779041083270096,-1.9951372153459488,-10.100796923252416,-7.885223207247999,-6.635061020452689,-6.261344610659105,-6.705170586639715,-2.5617698674284206,-9.253499062865211,-10.100796923252416,-4.5720294302077304,-6.222675469499951,-3.7645613367085256,-4.622243506401445,-9.541181135316993,-7.3816968859636205,-10.28311848004637,-5.024581983510178,-10.187808300242045,-2.36230880075777],[-3.712244886548001,-4.717475282130211,-2.783984370515817,-3.2216013768067646,-3.1683365236496233,-3.9038254558612397,-3.680790547058952,-9.119304544100272,-6.422989599216483,-10.323277348426208,-5.240838322200969,-3.0795261367137394,-3.173687619686372,-1.3126793991869439,-2.664381175855551,-4.9236074876178835,-7.895529112478156,-3.409705684122631,-2.051579832828198,-2.1011937452905483,-6.511074678280273,-3.816746183294981,-9.672689782285058,-6.168308164387673,-10.410288725415837,-5.511770729440288,-3.788398987959084],[-2.3427609160575655,-6.1024094410597085,-6.037870919922137,-6.507874549167873,-1.4153520955994334,-6.245510284700382,-6.17140231254666,-6.325552992373918,-5.51462277615759,-6.507874549167873,-6.245510284700382,-6.412564369363548,-6.325552992373918,-6.507874549167873,-1.2783714986201964,-6.412564369363548,-6.325552992373918,-6.1024094410597085,-6.1024094410597085,-6.245510284700382,-1.1002544477293865,-6.507874549167873,-6.245510284700382,-6.507874549167873,-6.507874549167873,-6.507874549167873,-4.859215923580492],[-3.6194933584945135,-7.047703539402737,-6.062419936041631,-7.671857848475732,-1.2114318817004575,-6.285563487355841,-6.824559988088527,-3.6311485020862624,-1.7851984157338756,-7.814958692116405,-7.489536291681777,-3.88766821455747,-6.036102627724257,-2.3543916630889337,-3.8417682258102714,-7.546694705521725,-7.9820127767795706,-5.48206824962703,-3.0008999219496366,-6.6910285954640045,-3.73872587983735,-7.2444138336487915,-5.438265626968637,-8.077322956583895,-4.682814563072537,-8.077322956583895,-1.4288566755523215],[-2.269183388314388,-6.573297799694782,-5.745479365449931,-2.8596367214634224,-1.7841347050080587,-4.144047900909572,-6.844091654118041,-7.7437746495925355,-2.175115871017978,-9.701519256294851,-4.956587127931601,-2.065933606191924,-5.060338632783727,-6.492693767280152,-2.4508837443961715,-5.604400767190025,-9.701519256294851,-5.648286082315182,-3.879460040714278,-3.864517937852428,-3.820986269894151,-5.091361528795721,-5.466205750947557,-9.883840813088806,-2.3336002683489516,-8.602906967626742,-2.0434097729831913],[-1.7539942375247688,-3.6841198980845076,-6.559311098803656,-8.439623965373157,-1.3654444296574595,-6.4075846625879045,-9.337565558579115,-8.238953269911006,-2.4389427631602505,-9.17051147391595,-8.902247487321269,-6.206031743866062,-3.641082386404525,-5.662416297277081,-2.2280575251437695,-2.6972144960398214,-9.432875738383439,-5.501050105659114,-3.5381974599631496,-6.907147094075184,-3.4685254837670296,-9.250554181589486,-8.071899185247839,-9.432875738383439,-3.424799925470261,-9.432875738383439,-1.8968318511898539],[-3.41157713428474,-6.728285208389976,-3.0909427430720093,-1.740264825689735,-2.5015190512398306,-4.817371901371758,-2.113210530516431,-6.807749379744223,-3.295792549094097,-6.252798951069294,-4.917797884336954,-4.632769841879079,-5.98877585293416,-4.66665175664129,-2.876759518067293,-7.603753945743875,-6.864465609186075,-7.187239001449126,-3.052336215755031,-2.2647479268985964,-4.9001580949910455,-5.348959516586179,-7.14773655847288,-7.454376544669275,-4.546351845156791,-8.807726750069811,-1.4656789800236865],[-5.082241389138844,-5.142393631993602,-4.276598353328924,-4.085216817689867,-5.7599683850109145,-2.174773615995364,-5.288621572218711,-6.090174110360315,-4.4715723308194235,-6.90687468303798,-4.432658655412265,-3.2277431063139637,-2.8212923556513845,-1.7681088393713913,-3.5156224239092224,-3.9518016568316168,-8.986316224717816,-2.1664590794141954,-3.3712131841519417,-3.1224483347145418,-2.2101893882141153,-3.5450716407123704,-3.140479750467313,-6.663111844521034,-5.51344438505264,-7.704225641127928,-2.2129736790077486],[-2.136265349667144,-7.648749930275526,-6.522163789565011,-8.503165258431594,-1.734614577170007,-6.50168525822147,-7.785325465281278,-3.642577960578998,-2.654272848600284,-8.454375094262163,-7.8613113722592,-2.3851781986138283,-6.363099094935324,-7.294204912594619,-2.116201767527298,-2.7907534570773387,-9.196312438991539,-1.7868731941606955,-3.848728831140585,-3.2942257030347744,-3.1971277688684197,-9.196312438991539,-7.0800569241889875,-9.196312438991539,-4.987152202340858,-9.196312438991539,-2.9363486388485507],[-6.182291496945648,-6.182291496945648,-6.182291496945648,-6.182291496945648,-6.182291496945648,-6.182291496945648,-6.182291496945648,-6.182291496945648,-6.182291496945648,-6.182291496945648,-6.182291496945648,-6.182291496945648,-6.182291496945648,-6.182291496945648,-6.182291496945648,-6.182291496945648,-6.182291496945648,-6.182291496945648,-6.182291496945648,-6.182291496945648,-0.057170565024993084,-6.182291496945648,-6.182291496945648,-6.182291496945648,-6.182291496945648,-6.182291496945648,-5.540437610773254],[-2.5722807952437394,-5.99205725679638,-4.319316764551239,-3.7284294070555273,-1.4225483817556492,-5.357231686671419,-4.331760927128789,-6.033757985995324,-2.364541745819138,-9.405183209323809,-4.850464566831816,-4.673556599383159,-3.74500437214974,-3.916576116332641,-2.322164557359624,-5.413979406021222,-9.0405400957359,-3.636862213530037,-2.9016138569514562,-3.2345687965875074,-3.9816438780223904,-4.905818082232694,-6.257588586460572,-10.13915238440401,-3.258597025348527,-8.070182142591468,-1.7281348556024394],[-3.2090119684802527,-6.334899523154303,-4.093299064417374,-7.59203503906228,-2.1586345703035548,-6.182995193953419,-7.849503332917564,-2.915257814589145,-2.7754710419906368,-9.550291023939893,-4.551024457450397,-4.707131510786311,-4.589272322367449,-6.243245073400844,-2.9689285157149676,-3.853927304671137,-7.00903143760076,-8.243133983378726,-2.8108514947509753,-2.1177557637833035,-3.256550330868065,-7.865503674264006,-5.380597024476005,-10.383200146874996,-5.201416596582911,-9.913196517629261,-0.9911300598753203],[-3.1682706209020797,-8.217706195099385,-5.878899838671022,-9.525219678366163,-2.3388918749787213,-7.172402459885784,-8.478432457562638,-1.1074718716074006,-2.3662341497302157,-10.456777882371107,-9.689522729657439,-4.418539855249544,-6.032391973858083,-7.21960886445558,-2.3367153961191565,-8.16191483547097,-10.719142146838596,-3.4624215669877803,-3.6797447588047447,-4.0251990917417855,-3.9002180815630756,-9.555991337032916,-5.18259559155831,-10.131355481936478,-4.204725796166784,-7.984774637419013,-1.5835253210583506],[-3.6907063474960813,-3.7341336409281,-3.2454721262149633,-4.020608712629846,-3.281297978688059,-5.0172437658127595,-3.1933271849501734,-7.7963898885987,-3.73111886626001,-9.35453450664525,-6.208229374611885,-2.257675168572427,-3.4112977818505237,-2.089862646254399,-6.096437968623768,-3.100705695069777,-8.949069398537086,-1.905375903432984,-1.9722545836234537,-1.9648676140617645,-9.274491798971713,-6.7831953510849425,-9.35453450664525,-7.31765257938421,-7.3735330377786665,-5.267158613739243,-3.2700350935700784],[-2.4677551327310105,-8.46601472297182,-8.561324902776146,-7.868177722216201,-0.5192363285514866,-8.561324902776146,-8.298960638308655,-8.46601472297182,-1.7429474349452256,-8.46601472297182,-7.919471016603751,-5.443374996497906,-8.561324902776146,-4.566800675836256,-2.7892609207035393,-8.561324902776146,-8.561324902776146,-6.268790145635601,-4.407140340198028,-7.973538237874027,-6.289199017266808,-8.379003345982191,-8.030696651713976,-8.46601472297182,-5.258107929474194,-8.561324902776146,-3.1228109057348257],[-1.596798460957614,-7.6001421705956735,-7.640964165115928,-5.344648685135478,-1.8921021056868312,-6.839336341561913,-8.110967794361665,-1.6228272590921338,-1.7628783045649916,-8.87310784640856,-7.001305669506969,-5.467159861987808,-8.179960665848615,-3.2183655671770013,-2.524218636471301,-8.293289351155618,-9.209580083029774,-4.57000847032435,-4.2425484264156506,-5.65423202154036,-7.560921457442392,-9.209580083029774,-7.307472556632853,-9.209580083029774,-6.877436187794184,-9.02725852623582,-2.172728230713227],[-2.254780968033424,-6.898209866138606,-2.027603216646053,-6.492744758030441,-2.462642464536694,-5.833499129146177,-6.898209866138606,-4.310445830910898,-2.0731012597852527,-6.898209866138606,-6.898209866138606,-6.42820623689287,-6.715888309344651,-6.898209866138606,-4.4558628307694015,-1.4955324842663262,-6.3675816150764355,-4.636446767664815,-5.766807754647505,-1.8703897472882491,-4.37248122183035,-4.348764695213034,-6.802899686334281,-4.473407140420311,-5.175443268397502,-6.898209866138606,-2.5557039896270073],[-3.872874353532438,-6.07983833755968,-5.605956228985375,-6.1495716755743555,-2.9181087352006836,-5.833140189836589,-6.998723104610883,-7.317176835729417,-3.8266394412494407,-8.857621876676566,-7.45070822835394,-4.745382824577915,-4.447858487031085,-5.448125692199715,-2.2255103117197566,-4.737230605516364,-9.03994343347052,-5.751541545953709,-3.132676045163294,-4.230201081753655,-7.038463433260397,-7.65364907235063,-6.230540738108023,-7.70494236673818,-8.16447469611662,-7.731610613820342,-0.3817890191036424],[-2.531179599331457,-6.00314605188182,-5.907835872077495,-4.694813232231641,-0.9292230185496455,-5.907835872077495,-6.00314605188182,-3.199785670975285,-2.3395844057521735,-6.00314605188182,-5.666673815260607,-3.8868905370792675,-4.0016660516716955,-5.009894278871537,-1.7362497244615698,-6.00314605188182,-6.00314605188182,-6.00314605188182,-5.820824495087865,-5.907835872077495,-3.118345339035111,-5.666673815260607,-5.907835872077495,-6.00314605188182,-4.568061526592498,-3.7731316517226094,-3.1699327078256037],[-2.154456318300654,-3.132028909232904,-3.2042402732214343,-3.554775966080049,-3.8320798875631166,-3.2625149066892174,-4.1318426237305275,-2.7847122791384975,-2.7534204117779435,-5.68607428491371,-5.271518205104294,-3.779792629468334,-3.3524684982622075,-3.8123859357235683,-2.644532475328425,-3.3676057306367433,-6.237872536056438,-3.6809218434868227,-2.7030074975159986,-1.86142386740762,-4.4723885304095425,-4.918696830481552,-2.8042850405884527,-7.783949528282384,-4.702039558487341,-8.486442571260568,-3.2910629924454486]],"Positions":{"100":3,"101":4,"102":5,"103":6,"104":7,"105":8,"106":9,"107":10,"108":11,"109":12,"110":13,"111":14,"112":15,"113":16,"114":17,"115":18,"116":19,"117":20,"118":21,"119":22,"120":23,"121":24,"122":25,"32":26,"97":0,"98":1,"99":2},"Threshold":0.018782003473122023}