add 05-presentation session

00-orga.md

@@ -106,7 +106,7 @@ Acquire a broad understanding of
 ## Outcome
 
 - A **review protocol** applying this understanding
-- The [evaluation criteria and resources for theses apply](https://digital-work-lab.github.io/handbook/docs/teaching/30_processes/30.40.theses.html) (length: approx. 15 pages)
+- [Criteria and resources](https://digital-work-lab.github.io/literature-review-seminar/docs/protocol.html) are available online
 - Submission: January 26, presentation: February 1
 
 <!-- 

05-presentation.md

@@ -0,0 +1,51 @@
+---
+marp: true
+header: 'Literature Review Seminar'
+theme: ub-theme
+paginate: true
+---
+
+
+# The Literature Review Seminar
+
+## Presentation of review protocols
+
+Seminar, Master
+
+Prof. Dr. Gerit Wagner
+Fakultät Wirtschaftsinformatik und Angewandte Informatik
+Universität Bamberg
+
+---
+
+# Presentation of review protocols
+
+1. Student presentation (10-15 min)
+2. Questions and discussion (5-10 min)
+3. Feedback
+
+TBD: Schein oder Flexnow?
+
+<!--
+
+# Topics
+
+TODO : include a table of students and topics (if )
+
+
+## Learning objectives
+
+Acquire a broad understanding of
+
+- the goals and types of literature reviews
+- the steps of the process
+- the qualities of a good review paper
+- the available research software
+
+## Outcome
+
+- A **review protocol** applying this understanding
+- The [evaluation criteria and resources for theses apply](https://digital-work-lab.github.io/handbook/docs/teaching/30_processes/30.40.theses.html) (length: approx. 15 pages)
+- Submission: January 26, presentation: February 1
+
+-->

Makefile

@@ -1,6 +1,6 @@
 run : slides
 
-slides: output/00-orga.html output/01-goals.html output/02-process.html output/03-qualities.html output/04-tools.html
+slides: output/00-orga.html output/01-goals.html output/02-process.html output/03-qualities.html output/04-tools.html output/05-presentation.html
 
 UID := $(shell id -u)
 GID := $(shell id -g)
@@ -21,3 +21,6 @@ output/03-qualities.html: 03-qualities.md assets/template/theme.css
 
 output/04-tools.html: 04-tools.md assets/template/theme.css
 	docker run --rm --init -v "$(PWD)":/home/marp/app/ -e LANG=${LANG} -e MARP_USER="${UID}:${GID}" marpteam/marp-cli 04-tools.md --theme-set assets/template/theme.css --html --allow-local-files -o output/04-tools.html
+
+output/05-presentation.html: 05-presentation.md assets/template/theme.css
+	docker run --rm --init -v "$(PWD)":/home/marp/app/ -e LANG=${LANG} -e MARP_USER="${UID}:${GID}" marpteam/marp-cli 05-presentation.md --theme-set assets/template/theme.css --html --allow-local-files -o output/05-presentation.html

docs/protocol.md

@@ -0,0 +1,47 @@
+---
+layout: default
+title: Review Protocol
+has_toc: true
+nav_order: 7
+---
+
+# Review Protocol
+
+Grading criteria:
+
+(length: approx. 15 pages)
+
+Topic
+Title
+Abstract (clarity)
+Keywords
+
+Introduction / Generativity statement
+Introduction / Clear topic, phenomenon, theory
+Introduction / Explicit and appropriate rationale
+Introduction / Clear questions or objectives
+Introduction / Optional: review type
+Introduction / Expected contributions
+Introduction / Clear scope
+
+Intermediary section (optional; note if it should be included)
+
+Methods / State type of review (justify if necessary)
+Methods / Description of search strategy and procedures (in line with review type)
+Methods / Descripiton of screening criteria
+Methods / Quality appraisal (if applicable)
+Methods / Data extraction procedures explicit and aligned with review type
+Methods / Data analysis and synthesis approach described
+
+Conclusion / Short limitations, implications for research and practice
+
+Appendix / List of contributors and responsibilities (optional)
+Appendix / timetable (mandatory)
+Appendix / list of tools and purposes (mandatory)
+Appendix / intended registration (optional)
+Appendix / other declarations (optional)
+
+
+Resources:
+
+TODO

output/02-process.html

@@ -18,7 +18,7 @@
 /* lead for first page */div#p>svg>foreignObject>section.lead :is(h2,marp-h2){letter-spacing:3px;font-size:14px}div#p>svg>foreignObject>section footer,div#p>svg>foreignObject>section.lead header{color:transparent}div#p>svg>foreignObject>section.lead:after{color:transparent}div#p>svg>foreignObject>section.overview_all{background-image:url("../assets/lecture_overview.jpg");background-size:100% 100%}div#p>svg>foreignObject>section.overview_part_1{background-image:url("../assets/lecture_overview.jpg");background-size:100% 100%}div#p>svg>foreignObject>section.overview_part_2{background-image:url("../assets/lecture_2-4.jpg");background-size:100% 100%}div#p>svg>foreignObject>section.overview_part_3{background-image:url("../assets/lecture_5-7.jpg");background-size:100% 100%}div#p>svg>foreignObject>section.overview_part_4{background-image:url("../assets/lecture_8-10.jpg");background-size:100% 100%}div#p>svg>foreignObject>section.overview_part_5{background-image:url("../assets/lecture_11-12.jpg");background-size:100% 100%}
 
 
-/* pages */div#p>svg>foreignObject>section:after{position:absolute;left:50px;right:50px;height:10px;bottom:5px;color:black}div#p>svg>foreignObject>section[data-marpit-scope-Ds41u4fj] p{padding-left:36px;text-indent:-36px}div#p>svg>foreignObject>section[data-marpit-scope-EeHbGhL5] p{padding-left:36px;text-indent:-36px}div#p>svg>foreignObject>section[data-marpit-scope-F2KchRqj] p{padding-left:36px;text-indent:-36px}div#p>svg>foreignObject>section[data-marpit-scope-4GwzRIQ4] p{padding-left:36px;text-indent:-36px}div#p>svg>foreignObject>section[data-marpit-advanced-background=background]{columns:initial!important;display:block!important;padding:0!important}div#p>svg>foreignObject>section[data-marpit-advanced-background=background]:after,div#p>svg>foreignObject>section[data-marpit-advanced-background=background]:before,div#p>svg>foreignObject>section[data-marpit-advanced-background=content]:after,div#p>svg>foreignObject>section[data-marpit-advanced-background=content]:before{display:none!important}div#p>svg>foreignObject>section[data-marpit-advanced-background=background]>div[data-marpit-advanced-background-container]{all:initial;display:flex;flex-direction:row;height:100%;overflow:hidden;width:100%}div#p>svg>foreignObject>section[data-marpit-advanced-background=background]>div[data-marpit-advanced-background-container][data-marpit-advanced-background-direction=vertical]{flex-direction:column}div#p>svg>foreignObject>section[data-marpit-advanced-background=background][data-marpit-advanced-background-split]>div[data-marpit-advanced-background-container]{width:var(--marpit-advanced-background-split,50%)}div#p>svg>foreignObject>section[data-marpit-advanced-background=background][data-marpit-advanced-background-split=right]>div[data-marpit-advanced-background-container]{margin-left:calc(100% - var(--marpit-advanced-background-split, 50%))}div#p>svg>foreignObject>section[data-marpit-advanced-background=background]>div[data-marpit-advanced-background-container]>figure{all:initial;background-position:center;background-repeat:no-repeat;background-size:cover;flex:auto;margin:0}div#p>svg>foreignObject>section[data-marpit-advanced-background=content],div#p>svg>foreignObject>section[data-marpit-advanced-background=pseudo]{background:transparent!important}div#p>svg>foreignObject>section[data-marpit-advanced-background=pseudo],div#p>svg[data-marpit-svg]>foreignObject[data-marpit-advanced-background=pseudo]{pointer-events:none!important}div#p>svg>foreignObject>section[data-marpit-advanced-background-split]{width:100%;height:100%}</style></head><body><div class="bespoke-marp-osc"><button data-bespoke-marp-osc="prev" tabindex="-1" title="Previous slide">Previous slide</button><span data-bespoke-marp-osc="page"></span><button data-bespoke-marp-osc="next" tabindex="-1" title="Next slide">Next slide</button><button data-bespoke-marp-osc="fullscreen" tabindex="-1" title="Toggle fullscreen (f)">Toggle fullscreen</button><button data-bespoke-marp-osc="presenter" tabindex="-1" title="Open presenter view (p)">Open presenter view</button></div><div id="p"><svg data-marpit-svg="" viewBox="0 0 1280 720"><foreignObject width="1280" height="720"><section id="1" data-header="Literature Review Seminar" data-paginate="true" data-theme="ub-theme" data-marpit-pagination="1" data-marpit-pagination-total="40" style="--header:Literature Review Seminar;--paginate:true;--theme:ub-theme;">
+/* pages */div#p>svg>foreignObject>section:after{position:absolute;left:50px;right:50px;height:10px;bottom:5px;color:black}div#p>svg>foreignObject>section[data-marpit-scope-RRS7aVAC] p{padding-left:36px;text-indent:-36px}div#p>svg>foreignObject>section[data-marpit-scope-WtT7TGUT] p{padding-left:36px;text-indent:-36px}div#p>svg>foreignObject>section[data-marpit-scope-yNGphjmT] p{padding-left:36px;text-indent:-36px}div#p>svg>foreignObject>section[data-marpit-scope-xfgxrRuw] p{padding-left:36px;text-indent:-36px}div#p>svg>foreignObject>section[data-marpit-advanced-background=background]{columns:initial!important;display:block!important;padding:0!important}div#p>svg>foreignObject>section[data-marpit-advanced-background=background]:after,div#p>svg>foreignObject>section[data-marpit-advanced-background=background]:before,div#p>svg>foreignObject>section[data-marpit-advanced-background=content]:after,div#p>svg>foreignObject>section[data-marpit-advanced-background=content]:before{display:none!important}div#p>svg>foreignObject>section[data-marpit-advanced-background=background]>div[data-marpit-advanced-background-container]{all:initial;display:flex;flex-direction:row;height:100%;overflow:hidden;width:100%}div#p>svg>foreignObject>section[data-marpit-advanced-background=background]>div[data-marpit-advanced-background-container][data-marpit-advanced-background-direction=vertical]{flex-direction:column}div#p>svg>foreignObject>section[data-marpit-advanced-background=background][data-marpit-advanced-background-split]>div[data-marpit-advanced-background-container]{width:var(--marpit-advanced-background-split,50%)}div#p>svg>foreignObject>section[data-marpit-advanced-background=background][data-marpit-advanced-background-split=right]>div[data-marpit-advanced-background-container]{margin-left:calc(100% - var(--marpit-advanced-background-split, 50%))}div#p>svg>foreignObject>section[data-marpit-advanced-background=background]>div[data-marpit-advanced-background-container]>figure{all:initial;background-position:center;background-repeat:no-repeat;background-size:cover;flex:auto;margin:0}div#p>svg>foreignObject>section[data-marpit-advanced-background=content],div#p>svg>foreignObject>section[data-marpit-advanced-background=pseudo]{background:transparent!important}div#p>svg>foreignObject>section[data-marpit-advanced-background=pseudo],div#p>svg[data-marpit-svg]>foreignObject[data-marpit-advanced-background=pseudo]{pointer-events:none!important}div#p>svg>foreignObject>section[data-marpit-advanced-background-split]{width:100%;height:100%}</style></head><body><div class="bespoke-marp-osc"><button data-bespoke-marp-osc="prev" tabindex="-1" title="Previous slide">Previous slide</button><span data-bespoke-marp-osc="page"></span><button data-bespoke-marp-osc="next" tabindex="-1" title="Next slide">Next slide</button><button data-bespoke-marp-osc="fullscreen" tabindex="-1" title="Toggle fullscreen (f)">Toggle fullscreen</button><button data-bespoke-marp-osc="presenter" tabindex="-1" title="Open presenter view (p)">Open presenter view</button></div><div id="p"><svg data-marpit-svg="" viewBox="0 0 1280 720"><foreignObject width="1280" height="720"><section id="1" data-header="Literature Review Seminar" data-paginate="true" data-theme="ub-theme" data-marpit-pagination="1" data-marpit-pagination-total="40" style="--header:Literature Review Seminar;--paginate:true;--theme:ub-theme;">
 <header>Literature Review Seminar</header>
 
 <h1>The Literature Review Seminar</h1>
@@ -220,6 +220,7 @@ <h2>Screening reliability</h2>
 <h2>Reporting the search and screen</h2>
 <p><img src="../assets/PRISMA-flowchart.png" alt="center" style="width:600px;" /></p>
 <p>The PRISMA flow chart (updated version by Tricco et al. 2018)</p>
+<p>An online version is available <a href="https://estech.shinyapps.io/prisma_flowdiagram/">here</a></p>
 </section>
 </foreignObject></svg><svg data-marpit-svg="" viewBox="0 0 1280 720"><foreignObject width="1280" height="720"><section data-header="Literature Review Seminar" data-paginate="true" data-theme="ub-theme" data-marpit-pagination="20" data-marpit-pagination-total="40" style="--header:Literature Review Seminar;--paginate:true;--theme:ub-theme;--marpit-advanced-background-split:60%;" data-marpit-advanced-background="background" data-marpit-advanced-background-split="right"><div data-marpit-advanced-background-container="true" data-marpit-advanced-background-direction="horizontal"><figure style="background-image:url(&quot;../assets/coffee.jpg&quot;);background-size:350px auto;"></figure></div></section></foreignObject><foreignObject width="40%" height="720"><section id="20" data-header="Literature Review Seminar" data-paginate="true" data-theme="ub-theme" data-marpit-pagination="20" data-marpit-pagination-total="40" style="--header:Literature Review Seminar;--paginate:true;--theme:ub-theme;--marpit-advanced-background-split:60%;" data-marpit-advanced-background="content" data-marpit-advanced-background-split="right">
 <header>Literature Review Seminar</header>
@@ -378,7 +379,7 @@ <h2>Discussion of the data analysis section</h2>
 <li>What outcomes would you expect ideally?</li>
 </ul>
 </section>
-</foreignObject></svg><svg data-marpit-svg="" viewBox="0 0 1280 720"><foreignObject width="1280" height="720"><section id="37" data-marpit-scope-Ds41u4fj="" data-header="Literature Review Seminar" data-paginate="true" data-theme="ub-theme" data-marpit-pagination="37" data-marpit-pagination-total="40" style="--header:Literature Review Seminar;--paginate:true;--theme:ub-theme;">
+</foreignObject></svg><svg data-marpit-svg="" viewBox="0 0 1280 720"><foreignObject width="1280" height="720"><section id="37" data-marpit-scope-RRS7aVAC="" data-header="Literature Review Seminar" data-paginate="true" data-theme="ub-theme" data-marpit-pagination="37" data-marpit-pagination-total="40" style="--header:Literature Review Seminar;--paginate:true;--theme:ub-theme;">
 <header>Literature Review Seminar</header>
 
 <h2>References</h2>
@@ -387,7 +388,7 @@ <h2>References</h2>
 <p>Boell, S. K., &amp; Cecez-Kecmanovic, D. (2014). A hermeneutic approach for conducting literature reviews and literature searches. <em>Communications of the Association for information Systems</em>, 34, 12. doi:<a href="https://aisel.aisnet.org/cais/vol34/iss1/12/">10.17705/1CAIS.03412</a></p>
 <p>Templier, M., &amp; Pare, G. (2018). Transparency in literature reviews: an assessment of reporting practices across review types and genres in top IS journals. <em>European Journal of Information Systems</em>, 27(5), 503-550. doi:<a href="https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/0960085X.2017.1398880">10.1080/0960085X.2017.1398880</a></p>
 </section>
-</foreignObject></svg><svg data-marpit-svg="" viewBox="0 0 1280 720"><foreignObject width="1280" height="720"><section id="38" data-marpit-scope-EeHbGhL5="" data-header="Literature Review Seminar" data-paginate="true" data-theme="ub-theme" data-marpit-pagination="38" data-marpit-pagination-total="40" style="--header:Literature Review Seminar;--paginate:true;--theme:ub-theme;">
+</foreignObject></svg><svg data-marpit-svg="" viewBox="0 0 1280 720"><foreignObject width="1280" height="720"><section id="38" data-marpit-scope-WtT7TGUT="" data-header="Literature Review Seminar" data-paginate="true" data-theme="ub-theme" data-marpit-pagination="38" data-marpit-pagination-total="40" style="--header:Literature Review Seminar;--paginate:true;--theme:ub-theme;">
 <header>Literature Review Seminar</header>
 
 <p><strong>Problem formulation</strong></p>
@@ -397,15 +398,15 @@ <h2>References</h2>
 <p>Hiebl, M. R. (2023). Sample selection in systematic literature reviews of management research. <em>Organizational Research MNethods</em>, 26(2), 229-261. doi:<a href="https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/1094428120986851">10.1177/109442812098685</a></p>
 <p>Knackstedt, R., &amp; Winkelmann, A. (2006). Online-Literaturdatenbanken im Bereich der Wirtschaftsinformatik: Bereitstellung wissenschaftlicher Literatur und Analyse von Interaktionen der Wissensteilung. <em>Wirtschaftsinformatik</em>, 1(48), 47-59. doi:<a href="https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11576-006-0006-1">10.1007/s11576-006-0006-1</a></p>
 </section>
-</foreignObject></svg><svg data-marpit-svg="" viewBox="0 0 1280 720"><foreignObject width="1280" height="720"><section id="39" data-marpit-scope-F2KchRqj="" data-header="Literature Review Seminar" data-paginate="true" data-theme="ub-theme" data-marpit-pagination="39" data-marpit-pagination-total="40" style="--header:Literature Review Seminar;--paginate:true;--theme:ub-theme;">
+</foreignObject></svg><svg data-marpit-svg="" viewBox="0 0 1280 720"><foreignObject width="1280" height="720"><section id="39" data-marpit-scope-yNGphjmT="" data-header="Literature Review Seminar" data-paginate="true" data-theme="ub-theme" data-marpit-pagination="39" data-marpit-pagination-total="40" style="--header:Literature Review Seminar;--paginate:true;--theme:ub-theme;">
 <header>Literature Review Seminar</header>
 
 <p>Wagner, G., Prester, J., &amp; Paré, G. (2021). Exploring the boundaries and processes of digital platforms for knowledge work: A review of information systems research. <em>The Journal of Strategic Information Systems</em>, 30(4), 101694. doi:<a href="https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S096386872100041X">10.1016/j.jsis.2021.101694</a></p>
 <p><strong>Screen</strong></p>
 <p>Tricco, A. C., Lillie, E., Zarin, W., O'Brien, K. K., Colquhoun, H., Levac, D., ... &amp; Straus, S. E. (2018). PRISMA extension for scoping reviews (PRISMA-ScR): checklist and explanation.<br />
 <em>Annals of Internal Medicine</em>, 169(7), 467-473. doi:<a href="https://www.acpjournals.org/doi/full/10.7326/M18-0850">10.7326/M18-0850</a></p>
 </section>
-</foreignObject></svg><svg data-marpit-svg="" viewBox="0 0 1280 720"><foreignObject width="1280" height="720"><section id="40" data-marpit-scope-4GwzRIQ4="" data-header="Literature Review Seminar" data-paginate="true" data-theme="ub-theme" data-marpit-pagination="40" data-marpit-pagination-total="40" style="--header:Literature Review Seminar;--paginate:true;--theme:ub-theme;">
+</foreignObject></svg><svg data-marpit-svg="" viewBox="0 0 1280 720"><foreignObject width="1280" height="720"><section id="40" data-marpit-scope-xfgxrRuw="" data-header="Literature Review Seminar" data-paginate="true" data-theme="ub-theme" data-marpit-pagination="40" data-marpit-pagination-total="40" style="--header:Literature Review Seminar;--paginate:true;--theme:ub-theme;">
 <header>Literature Review Seminar</header>
 
 <p><strong>Data analysis</strong></p>