Skip to content

Conversation

@aatchison
Copy link
Collaborator

🚀 Complete HTTP Streams Transport Implementation

This PR completes the HTTP Streams transport implementation that was documented in v1.1.0 but never fully committed to the repository.

✨ What's New

🔧 HTTP Streams Transport (/mcp endpoint)

  • Full MCP Protocol Compliance: Complete implementation of HTTP Streams transport as per MCP specification
  • Session Management: Secure session-based communication with UUID session IDs
  • Bidirectional Communication: POST for client→server, SSE for server→client responses
  • Health Endpoint: /health endpoint for service monitoring
  • CORS Support: Full CORS headers for web client compatibility
  • Security: ReadHeaderTimeout configuration, proper error handling

🧪 Comprehensive Testing Infrastructure

  • 42 Unit Tests: All passing with race detection
  • 3 Integration Test Scripts: Complete end-to-end testing for all transports
    • test_stdio_integration.py - STDIO transport testing
    • test_sse_integration.py - SSE transport testing
    • test_http_streams_integration.py - HTTP Streams transport testing
  • Parallel Testing: GitHub Actions matrix strategy for concurrent transport testing
  • Make Targets: Individual and combined test targets for all transports

🔄 CI/CD Enhancements

  • GitHub Actions Workflow: Matrix strategy testing all three transports in parallel
  • Python Dependencies: Proper requests package configuration
  • Go 1.21+ Support: Updated build requirements
  • Linting Integration: golangci-lint with comprehensive checks

🏗️ Architecture

HTTP Streams Transport Flow:

  1. Initialize: POST /mcp with MCP initialize message → Returns session ID
  2. SSE Stream: GET /mcp with session ID → Establishes server→client stream
  3. Messages: POST /mcp with session ID → Responses via SSE stream
  4. Health: GET /health → Service status monitoring

Session Management:

  • Cryptographically secure UUID session IDs
  • Thread-safe session storage with mutex protection
  • Automatic cleanup on client disconnect
  • Session validation for all requests

🧹 Code Quality Improvements

Major Refactoring:

  • Reduced Complexity: Broke down complex functions into smaller helpers
    • handleMessage → 7 helper functions
    • handleSSEStream → 4 helper functions
  • Error Handling: Comprehensive error checking for all operations
  • Security: Added HTTP server timeouts, proper CORS handling
  • Formatting: Applied gofmt to all files
  • Linting: Fixed all golangci-lint issues (line length, error messages, style)

🧪 Test Results

✅ All Tests Passing:

Unit Tests: 42/42 PASSING
Integration Tests: 3/3 PASSING
- STDIO Transport: ✅ WORKING
- SSE Transport: ✅ WORKING  
- HTTP Streams Transport: ✅ WORKING
Build: ✅ PASSING
Lint: ✅ PASSING (0 issues)

📋 Transport Comparison

Feature STDIO SSE HTTP Streams
Use Case CLI tools Web apps Web apps
Communication Bidirectional Bidirectional Bidirectional
Client→Server stdin POST /message POST /mcp
Server→Client stdout SSE /sse SSE /mcp
Session Management Process-based Session ID Session ID
CORS Support N/A
Health Check N/A /health /health

🔧 Usage Examples

HTTP Streams Transport:

# Start server
./mcp-server -transport=http-streams -addr=8080

# Test with integration script
python3 scripts/test_http_streams_integration.py 8080

# Manual testing
curl -X POST http://localhost:8080/mcp \
  -H "Content-Type: application/json" \
  -d '{"jsonrpc":"2.0","id":1,"method":"initialize","params":{"protocolVersion":"2024-11-05","capabilities":{},"clientInfo":{"name":"test","version":"1.0.0"}}}'

All Transports Testing:

make test-integration-all  # Test all transports
make test-integration-stdio
make test-integration-sse  
make test-integration-http-streams

🚨 Quality Control Note

This PR addresses the critical quality control issue where HTTP Streams transport was documented in v1.1.0 release notes but the implementation was never committed. All three transports now have:

  • Complete implementations
  • Comprehensive test coverage
  • Integration test scripts
  • CI/CD validation

🎯 Breaking Changes

None - This is purely additive functionality. All existing STDIO and SSE transport functionality remains unchanged and fully backward compatible.

📚 Documentation

  • Updated README with HTTP Streams transport usage
  • Added comprehensive integration test scripts
  • Enhanced Makefile with new test targets
  • GitHub Actions workflow documentation

Ready for Review

  • All tests passing
  • No linting issues
  • Complete documentation
  • Backward compatible
  • Production ready

- Implement HTTP Streams transport with proper []byte interface
- Add comprehensive tests for HTTP Streams functionality
- Update main.go to support HTTP Streams transport selection
- Add debug logging support for HTTP Streams
- Update Dockerfile to use http-streams as default transport
- Add HTTP_STREAMS.md documentation
- Add test_http_streams.py integration test script

This fixes the missing HTTP Streams implementation that was documented
in v1.1.0 but never actually committed to the repository.
✅ MAJOR BREAKTHROUGH: HTTP Streams transport now fully working!

🔧 Fixed critical HTTP Streams issues:
- Added initial SSE connection message to prevent client hangs
- Fixed test script to handle initialize request properly
- Updated HTTPStreamsClient to avoid duplicate initialize requests
- Added session management and proper protocol flow

🧪 Enhanced comprehensive testing:
- Created test_all_transports.py for testing all 3 transports
- All transports now passing comprehensive tests:
  * STDIO: ✅ All tests passing
  * SSE: ✅ All tests passing
  * HTTP Streams: ✅ All tests passing
- Added parallel testing capability
- Updated integration test scripts

🚀 HTTP Streams transport features:
- Single /mcp endpoint for both GET (SSE) and POST (messages)
- Session-based communication with header-based session IDs
- SSE format responses with 'data: ' prefixes
- Proper connection establishment and message handling
- Full MCP protocol compliance

🎯 Quality control improvements:
- Comprehensive test coverage for all transport mechanisms
- Integration tests verify actual protocol functionality
- Parallel testing ensures no transport interference

This completes the HTTP Streams implementation that was documented
but never properly committed in v1.1.0.
- Added server startup/shutdown logic to SSE integration test script
- Now matches HTTP Streams script pattern with built-in server management
- All three transport integration tests now working perfectly:
  - STDIO: ✅ PASSING
  - SSE: ✅ PASSING
  - HTTP Streams: ✅ PASSING
- Fixed Makefile targets for all transport testing
- Comprehensive parallel testing confirmed working
- Fixed function signature line lengths by splitting parameters
- Fixed error message capitalization (stylecheck)
- Added package comment for stylecheck compliance
- All linting issues resolved
- All tests passing (42 unit tests + 3 integration tests)
- HTTP Streams transport fully functional and compliant
- Split matrix-based transport-tests into separate jobs
- stdio-transport-test: dedicated STDIO transport testing
- sse-transport-test: dedicated SSE transport testing
- http-streams-transport-test: dedicated HTTP Streams transport testing
- Updated job dependencies for build and docker jobs
- Improved CI clarity and debugging capabilities
- All three test scripts (STDIO, SSE, HTTP Streams) now handle their own server lifecycle
- Added proper argument parsing to all scripts
- Fixed syntax errors and exception handling
- Updated GitHub Actions workflow to use new self-contained scripts
- Added Python cache files to .gitignore

Each script can now be run independently and manages its own server process,
making them suitable for CI/CD pipeline execution.
- Remove hardcoded /workspace/mcp-server-framework paths
- Scripts now work correctly in CI environment
- All three transport tests validated working locally
@aatchison aatchison marked this pull request as ready for review June 7, 2025 03:40
- Add Trivy vulnerability scanner with SARIF upload to GitHub Security tab
- Restrict release job to only run for tags on main branch
- Add branch check in release job to ensure tag is on main branch
@github-advanced-security
Copy link

This pull request sets up GitHub code scanning for this repository. Once the scans have completed and the checks have passed, the analysis results for this pull request branch will appear on this overview. Once you merge this pull request, the 'Security' tab will show more code scanning analysis results (for example, for the default branch). Depending on your configuration and choice of analysis tool, future pull requests will be annotated with code scanning analysis results. For more information about GitHub code scanning, check out the documentation.

- Phase 1: Core tests and quality checks run in parallel
  - test, lint, security, transport tests
- Phase 2: Build jobs run after core tests pass
  - build and docker jobs depend on all Phase 1 jobs
- Phase 3: Release runs last after everything passes
  - release job depends on build and docker jobs

This provides better logical flow and ensures builds only run
after all quality checks pass.
@aatchison aatchison merged commit c3da5e8 into main Jun 7, 2025
14 checks passed
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

3 participants