Values not working

[yMiZeD]

Hello,

I'm trying to deploy zitadel in my own helm chart, I add zitadel as a dependencies in my chart.yaml file.

Here is my values file :

zitadel:
  masterkey: x123456789012345678901234567891y
  configmapConfig:
    ExternalSecure: false
    ExternalDomain: zitadel-dev.test
    TLS:
      Enabled: false
    Database:
      Postgres:
        Host: postgres-zitadel-dev-0
        Port: 5432
        Database: zitadel
        MaxOpenConns: 20
        MaxIdleConns: 10
        MaxConnLifetime: 30m
        MaxConnIdleTime: 5m
        User:
          Username: zitadel
          SSL:
            Mode: verify-full
        Admin:
          Username: postgres
          SSL:
            Mode: verify-full

  secretConfig:
    Database:
      Postgres:
        User:
          Password: xyz
        Admin:
          Password: Test123

  dbSslCaCrtSecret: postgres-cert
  dbSslAdminCrtSecret: postgres-cert
  dbSslUserCrtSecret: zitadel-cert

  ingress:
    enabled: true
    hosts:
      - host: zitadel-dev.test
        paths:
          - path: /
            pathType: Prefix

postgresql:
  fullnameOverride: "postgres-zitadel-dev"

  volumePermissions:
    enabled: true

  tls:
    enabled: true
    certificatesSecret: postgres-cert
    certFilename: "tls.crt"
    certKeyFilename: "tls.key"

  auth:
    postgresPassword: "Test123"

But when I try to apply my file I get this error :

helm install zitadel .\zitadel\ -f .\zitadel\values.yaml
Error: INSTALLATION FAILED: execution error at (zitadel/charts/zitadel/templates/secret_zitadel-masterkey.yaml:2:4): Either set .Values.zitadel.masterkey xor .Values.zitadel.masterkeySecretName

[eliobischof]

I think using ZITADEL in an umbrella chart doesn't work ATM. Would you mind creating an issue with a reproducible setup so we can plan and track the fix?

[eliobischof]

Also, can you explain your use case, please? Why would you like to deploy ZITADEL as an umbrella chart dependency? Which problem does that solve for you?

[yMiZeD]

Hello it's not solving a problem for me, I'm just trying to deploy my whole application with dependence in 1 chart.

[yMiZeD]

It's not a good usage for you ?

[eliobischof]

It might increase the ease of use to have an umbrella chart but I think you also sacrifice control over day two operations in general.
Let's say you have the database and zitadel as separate charts, you can upgrade the database first, and only once you're confident that everything still works as expected you might want to upgrade zitadel. If you do it this way, there is kind of no point in binding the tools together, right?
What's your take on this and what tools do you actually want to tie together?