Change icon from the blue "Google Chrome" icon to something more unique to Ungoogled-Chromium (and less "Googley")?

[GalacticSun]

Just a suggestion...
Thanks and keep up the good work.

[PF4Public]

Related: #759

[NukeThief]

LOVE IT!

[jstkdng]

maybe putting a U on the middle of the chromium icon.
Edit: rough example, i'm not the best at using gimp

[VIPVF]

23

[Rexadev]

I hate the 6 - 6 - * icon

[Futur3H4wk]

love it if only it were in red it would be perfect

[Eloston]

I consider changing the icon to be rebranding the browser. I historically disagreed with rebranding because I think it sends a wrong message about what ungoogled-chromium is. However, I do see the value in adding some small indications that the browser is ungoogled-chromium and not Chromium.

I would be willing to have an option for (not require!) ungoogled-chromium builds to include small changes of this manner. Perhaps these changes would be suitable for contrib?

[jstkdng]

Well, at least shortcut icons can be changed when packaging, dunno if icons that appear inside chromium can, like the one in the about chromium page

or chromium://version

Otherwise, icons could be uploaded to the contrib repo, might need someone to polish them first though.

[GalacticSun]

Was actually thinking something a bit more of a departure from the logo entirely - something entirely original, something that captures the spirit of the project instead of still being derivitive.

[PF4Public]

entirely original

But this project is a derivative in a large part.

[GalacticSun]

entirely original

But this project is a derivative in a large part.

The decision to remove Google's code was original. I was referring to honouring that, instead of the original project.

[jvzr]

In the spirit of Elaston's comments (I hope), I had a very quick try at making an icon that's very obviously "Chromium", and still subtly "not Google".. I'm no visual designer so I'm sure somebody else will have a better idea

(I was first looking into turning the center circle into another shape, like a octagon, but it looked clunky and would probably be lost at small sizes. Then I followed jstkdng's idea of including a "U" somehow)

[dioxias]

big fan of this design. unsure how it would be with regards to being a similar logo to chromium (legally wise), but this is the icon i use for my shortcuts for ungoogled

[sakkamade]

...something entirely original, something that captures the spirit of the project instead of still being derivitive.

For entirely original icon this project must have the entierly original name.

On my opinion the furthest changes could take a place - modify original chromium icon.
Well, I like the chromium icon, so I think change the colors would be enough.

Edit: Aw.. Haven't notice

Related: #759

Then yeah, makes sense...

[jstkdng]

@jvzr
I like your design, though, that U is really subtle. What if you removed the center shape and had a giant U instead, like how you have now, but remove the upper border from the circle and just have a white border representing the U, also extending the shadows.

[u9000-Nine]

I've actually been thinking about this since I installed ungoogled-chromium a few months ago. I agree with @roshiajin-kunai that it should be green. It's clearly different and clearly chromium, just like the project. The chromium icon is a light blue, which is one of the three main colors we see (RGB) (over simplification); a light green is distinct from a light blue yet also RGB and recongnizably similar. It'd be interesting to see, perhaps, how a light green version of @jvzr 's design, which also incorporates the U, would look.

[jvzr]

@jstkdng That was my original exploration but it didn't work at all, in my opinion:

@u9000-Nine Something like that? (I tried to be faithful to Chrome's original green hues)

[johannesrld]

I Disagree with the choice of green (people might confuse it with bromite) but the general idea is really nice, maybe burgundy or purple would be better?

[networkException]

👍 for purple (maybe something like this?)

[johannesrld]

yeah that looks nice

[dreaddr]

Maybe once a name has been chosen for the project, then focus on a new logo? The project is becoming more and more popular by the day and will probably get Google's attention sooner than later.

[Tchoor]

UnGoogled Chromium Free Icon - Download and Use


UnGoogled Chromium Free Icon - Download

[PF4Public]

The second one is kind of interesting :)

[dreaddr]

I agree, the second one has a unique look to it

[kgwooo]

Where is the icon that come with this version? I mean the square with rounded corners ico, btw. The folder to be precise!

[kgwooo]

Taken care of...Thanks for your efforts, eloston!

[Tchoor]

Where is the icon that come with this version? I mean the square with rounded corners ico, btw. The folder to be precise!

All icons are inside .exe file itself

[PF4Public]

Let me summarize both discussions (name-changing and icon-changing) so that we are all on the same page and avoid reiterating things again and again:

• There is no solid agreement on the new name (this obstacle could be overcame by arbitrary decree)
• There is no agreement on the new icon either (this obstacle could be overcame by arbitrary decree)
• Changing anything touches so many parts so there is some kind of resistance and motivation not to do anything
• Changing anything suggests some work to be done so there is some kind of resistance and motivation not to do anything
• The probability of Google suing ungoogled-chromium is on the scale from small to non-existing

So to sum up: if something works, don't fix it unless anything from the above put in motion, no amount of complaining, arguing, persuasion succeeds.

[GalacticSun]

This thread was only about changing the icon, not the name. I think that's a different issue deserving of its own thread.

I'd suggest, actually, to keep things simple:

• Put this icon change question to a vote/poll with a wider audience.

• And also solicit new tangible icon ideas at design websites and forums.

The point of this thread was to generate initial interest by others who want to change the icon from the original Google toilet-bowl-swirl icon.

[u9000-Nine]

Okay, why not we create a poll somewhere (mailing list? notification?) where users can vote on the top 5ish icons from this list, and then we can be done with this. There is clearly a lot of sentiment of “let’s vote now” throughout the years, and I don’t think that if we continue discussing it we’ll get anywhere. (It’s impossible to please everybody, so let’s just find something most people can agree on.)

Here are what I think are the proposed icons that are most likely to be approved:

• 
• 
• 
• 
• 

Since many of these are similar, we should probably use ranked voting. (Also, it seems we’re totally fine to use / derive from the chromium logo.)

[GalacticSun]

I recommend putting it out to a larger group of designers first to get more icons before voting on anything.

There's no point in rushing this, it's worth taking time to solicit more icons to get it right.

[u9000-Nine]

I’m not 100% opposed to commissioning a few designs first, but if we do that I think we should put a time limit on it. With all due respect GlacticSun, I think two and a half years is enough time before sending out a poll.

[GalacticSun]

Well, Github isn't really the place to solicit polls on designs or designs themselves since it is made up of a limited set of people, most of whom are developers. That's why it languished for so long.

I'll leave this in the hands of a project leader or someone else who wants to get this done and take the initiative to solicit a larger group of people than the handful in this thread. I've switched to LibreWolf, anyway, to be honest.

Good luck!

[u9000-Nine]

If I were to make a quick poll somewhere (not google forms), would you guys (maintainers) be willing to send it out somehow to the users? It’d be sad to see this years-long discussion fall flat right at the end just because OP’s done.

[SecularSteve]

They might've been onto something.

Here's my idea for the new logo proposal:

ZIP contains the SVG and PNG.

ungoogled chromium new.zip

[PF4Public]

Bears a slight similarity to Poké Ball :D

[9Morello]

lovely Poke Ball 🍡

[rany2]

This is now very important because of ungoogled-software/ungoogled-chromium-flatpak#3.

[SecularSteve]

Sometimes a "Copper Fist" comes a long way in the world of Open Source.
It's how KDE and Ubuntu've remained consistently active all these years after all.
Otherwise they'd end up like AppImage.

And I don't mind it, let alone notice it.
In fact, whatever you did finally made the icon viewable in plain SVG mode.
So thank you in return for that at least.

[rany2]

I actually just cut and pasted the paths in InkScape. That's how I fixed that issue :)

[Cubik65536]

So you picked one randomly and used it?

The requirement is very weird by any means to be honest... Although, in my opinion, the icon added there is probably the only proposal that keeps the original "Chromium" icon feeling without still touching the trademark issue...

Another problem now is... do we change the icon on other platforms (or maybe even the icon of this GitHub organization)?

[networkException]

do we change the icon on other platforms (or maybe even the icon of this GitHub organization)?

no, we'll not touch the icon unless its required for now. For consistency I'd say all platforms that don't allow the original icon should use the one flatpak uses now.

There will be a proper new icon eventually(tm), alongside a rename.

[Futur3H4wk]

Love it, had to run around and update all my boxes. BRILLIANT !!

[pbryan]

Holy cow, the new red icon kinda shocked me when I opened UGC this morning.

[Pen-Man]

shocked me too, i checked to see if it was due to my icon pack, but then I realized it had officially changed. To be honest, I didn't like it; it's too conspicuous. Still, thanks to the person who prepared it.

[Futur3H4wk]

Love it, had to run around and update all my boxes. BRILLIANT !!

[pbryan]

I'm now over the shock. The red Pokéball is growing on me. 😉

[TimmermanV]

I like the shape. I'd prefer a different color.

[Maia-Everett]

I agree with TimmermanV. The shape is good, it's the colors that give me pause. If we're sticking with red tones, maybe some kind of softer coral?

[cyan-2048]

the icon does indeed look like a pokeball lmao, can someone just make the chromium logo red-ish instead of making an entirely new one?

[SecularSteve]

I don't think it would fly.
I mean, the FlatPeople are making it explicitly clear that it needs to be legally distinct enough to differentiate from the original thing.

All I did was make it thanks to a post of a now presumably banned/deleted user who's finished it half-way, and I just took over because I thought they were onto something. That's why I'm not going to be a fat-head about it.

I'm just as surprised as you that it somehow got approved some way. I'm thankful for that at least.

[cyan-2048]

what if?

[cyan-2048]

nah i think there should be a more proper way of picking the logo, what's surprising is they just took it from here, could've made an announcement somewhere else for a logo making competition or whatever.

[rany2]

@cyan-2048 when I switched the logo, it was just so that I could get rid of the target on my back. I know it's abrupt but it beats having the flatpak pulled.

[Maia-Everett]

I was very confused when my Ungoogled Chromium icon changed from blue to red.

I think this new logo looks too aggressive. Maybe change it to a softer color?

[SecularSteve]

Kind of tried that already, but it looked kind of washed out.

I chose red because you don't usually see that on icons connected to pure Chromium (you have yellow for the Canary Chrome edition, and that's really it), none of the other icons here really went for a red design, and I wanted it to look like a "forbidden entry" sign to symbolise that it's "google free" based on what the now deleted/banned user was going for.

Was honestly kind of afraid that it looked too much like the Opera Logo, but I'm not going to look into the mouth of a stallion with a santa hat on.

But hey, that's just me making leeway to ease some people in on this abrupt change. I'm no expert, but I am trying to be nice about it.

[rhrgrt]

The change caught me off guard, but I tracked this thread down to say I love it. I hope it ends up being the official icon.

[alltheseas]

I feel like Arnold Schwarzenegger's red eye from Terminator is watching me with the new red icon

[pbryan]

I feel like Arnold Schwarzenegger's red eye from Terminator is watching me with the new red icon

"Come with me if you want a free and open-source variant of the Chromium web browser that removes all Google-specific web services."

[hs7t]

I think the new one has a slightly aggressive feel to it—straying a bit more from the original might help?

five-minute sketch:

SVG (∞) PNG (512x512)

featuring a very subtle gradient à la Chromium

[3400877]

Are proposals sill looked into?

[SecularSteve]

Looks great! However, some users may get flashbacks of a cursed program called uTorrent when they see the letter 'u' here. Or is it just me?

It's not green, so it must be you.
Hope you're using qBit or Tribler at least...

[PF4Public]

of a cursed program called uTorrent

1.8 versions were actually quite good

[tappzz]

Hope you're using qBit or Tribler at least...

Yeah, I've heard about qBit, Transmission etc. But at the end of the day, nothing's better than Mediaget.
/s

[SecularSteve]

Hope you're using qBit or Tribler at least...

Yeah, I've heard about qBit, Transmission etc. But at the end of the day, nothing's better than Mediaget.

Tell me it somehow works with KODI, and you'll immediately win me over.

[hs7t]

Folks! This doesn't seem like the right place for you to have this conversation—maybe email each other? GitHub notifs are sort of agressive.

[Futur3H4wk]

How about something like this?
I've never had so much trouble getting GIP to do something close to what I want in my life.
What A pain for a LOL.

[David7ce]

Here's another proposal. without the 666 of Google on the external circle which is formed by the white circle that hiddes the "right angles" of the 3 pieces of blue.

[Futur3H4wk]

I think it's great the way it is, and you are all going to talk about it for months and not make any progress. that's why someone had to just act, bravo for the initiative.

[igonro]

I was reviewing this thread and I wanted to bring up more proposals. So, I wanted a cool logo that would be different enough from the Chromium one, but still reminiscent of it. So I asked ChatGPT and it suggested this:

But I know that the SVG file is needed, so I tried my Powerpoint skills to create some logos based on the colors and names of my earlier proposal with some color and name changes: Osmium, Oxygen -> Oxidium, Copper -> Coprium. Of course these are just ideas, any feedback is more than welcome.

I hope you like them and that they can serve as inspiration to someone.

SVG links:
osmium.svg
oxidium.svg
coprium.svg

[Futur3H4wk]

How about aurum

[igonro]

How about aurum

@Futur3H4wk do you want one with yellowish/gold colors or just to propose that name? Also another possibility related to gold would be "Aureum" which is "golden" in latin.

[Futur3H4wk]

I do like the idea of a gold color scheme. I had thought of Aureum (which I also like) but went with the Latin. Either would be fine by me.