Skip to content
This repository has been archived by the owner on Mar 11, 2022. It is now read-only.

DAO Voting - Votes not added #290

Open
MitchellUnknown opened this issue Jan 15, 2022 · 2 comments
Open

DAO Voting - Votes not added #290

MitchellUnknown opened this issue Jan 15, 2022 · 2 comments

Comments

@MitchellUnknown
Copy link

I wanted to test the voting process, but I ran into some errors. I voted on proposal 2 and my votes where never added by the DAO. Despite the message: Vote recorded, thank you. I think I did everything right, this is what I did:

For your information all my boba tokens are staked in the 5% fixed saving account, so I voted with my xBoba only.

  1. I delegated my xBoba votes to my own address (confirmation with metamask)
  2. After my votes appeared in 'Total Votes', I pressed 'vote' on proposal 2 and pressed 'vote no'. After paying the fee, the DAO confirmed my vote with: Vote recorded, thank you. But the votes where never added.

image

@CAPtheorem
Copy link
Contributor

Thanks - will look! When you say the votes were never added, you mean that the displayed number of 'no' votes on the gateway did not update immediately to reflect your additional no votes? So if you had 100 xBOBA, and you clicked "No", your expectation is that the "No" value will immediately increase by +100?

@MitchellUnknown
Copy link
Author

Thanks. After I delegated my xBoba to my own address, it displayed my total amount of votes. So let say I had 100 xBoba, I had now 100 total votes. When I decided to click "No" I did not got any visual feedback on how many votes I was going to vote "No" with. But I assumed it was the total amount of xBoba I had delegated. It directed me directly to metamask to sign the 'cast vote'. When the transaction was confirmed, the DAO showed the message: Vote recorded, thank you. And my expectation was indeed that the value would increase with +100xboba, but this didn't happen. So I asked Shaners from the team, and he said it could take a few minutes, before the votes are added. But it never did, and 1 day later the proposal voting window expired without my votes being included. I know that my votes where not included, because I voted with a significant amount of xBoba.

  • My first thought was that I forgot to enter the amount of votes I wanted to cast. So maybe I did vote succesful on "no" but with 0 votes. I don't know if that's even possible, because I assume your voting with all of your delegated votes.

  • Second thought was that I did not delegate my xBoba to my own address. But the blockexplorer confirmed that my votes where delegated correctly. And also broadcasting my vote.

If you want the blockexplorer transaction data for the delegating and casting vote, let me know.

Sign up for free to subscribe to this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in.
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

2 participants