Why does this default stone generator not work?

[DemonSlayer112]

Im confused as why this doesnt work:

	"stoneGen": [
		{
			"id": "minecraft:stone",
			"weight": 100.0,
			"minY": 0
		},
		{
			"id": "minecraft:deepslate",
			"weight": 75.0,
			"minY": -64,
			"maxY": -1
		},
		{
			"id": "minecraft:tuff",
			"weight": 25.0,
			"minY": -64,
			"maxY": -1
		}
	]

[null2264]

Can you elaborate on what doesn't work?

Answer: After investigating further, the problem is actually maxY and minY value is flipped, maxY value should be in minY and vice versa. A better more straight forward range config is planned.

Currently proposed range config design:

{
    "range": "[-64, -1)"  // This would mean -64 up to (but not including) -1
    "range": "[-64, -1]"  // This would mean -64 up to (including) -1
    "range": "(-64, -1)"  // This would mean -63 up to (but not including) -1
}

[null2264]

Also, make sure that the file is saved properly and your generated block is being generated BELOW y=-1

[DemonSlayer112]

Also, make sure that the file is saved properly and your generated block is being generated BELOW y=-1

This sure is odd, so far it only works for deepslate cobblestone and not stone...
Ok! I removed the example custom stoneGen and the default one started working! :D
Idk why the custom would do this tho, it required a bedrock block i thought?

[null2264]

It should be, from my testing, there are no instances where it would generate without a modifier. Since it's working now, I'll mark this as answer. As for the custom stoneGen bug, can you provide me with your bugged config file? for when I have the time to look into it deeper.

[DemonSlayer112]

Alright this may be the issue here.
Turns out it does work but not at y -1, which is sort of odd?

Here's the config: cobblegen.zip

Figured stone having minY: 0 would make sure this doesnt happen?
And cobbled deepslate seems to work just fine for this.

[null2264]

Yeah, minY is not inclusive. I'll add an option for inclusive to avoid future confusion.