Adding Speaker (sonos) to groups interrupts playback

[hosh0815]

What version of Music Assistant has the issue?

2.3.0 RC3

What version of the Home Assistant Integration have you got installed?

2024.10.1

Have you tried everything in the Troubleshooting FAQ and reviewed the Open and Closed Issues and Discussions to resolve this yourself?

• Yes

The problem

like described on #2692 I get interrupted by adding some speaker... now I can see, that after checking an speakers Checkbox, it will be automaticly unchecked...

How to reproduce

open speaker which is started (even grouped with two others) an then add some more: then I can see, that the checkboxes are empty after selection.

Music Providers

apple, TuneIn, Local FileShare

Player Providers

Sonos

Full log output

No response

Additional information

No response

What version of Home Assistant Core are your running

2024.10.3

What type of installation are you running?

Home Assistant OS

On what type of hardware are you running?

Raspberry Pi

[OzGav]

A slight interruption when a player is joined is normal.

You haven’t attached the full log as requested. You haven’t provided all of the information requested in the troubleshooting page. Please edit your report with all of this information.

Which Sonos provider?

Screenshots might be helpful to show what you are seeing as we don’t see any problems with Sonos.

[hosh0815]

didn´t work with beta before... sorry
music-assistant_logBeta.log

[OzGav]

Can you provide a step by step with screenshots so we properly understand the issue.

[hosh0815]

1. select starting speaker (sonos) or already grouped speaker
2. start playing music
3. choose the grouped speaker and begin adding one or more speaker with checkboxes
4. after I selected one speaker and then another, I realized, that the first speakers checkbox is empty

also the music interrupts at the beginning,.. seems to stabalize after time playing

[OzGav]

Just to confirm which provider. Sonos S1 or Sonos?

[hosh0815]

Sonos...

[OzGav]

Can’t recreate this. Does the additional player join despite the status of the checkbox? If so, can you refresh the browser page and see if the checkboxes are correct then

[hosh0815]

it happens in the moment checking some other speaker... like it losses my marking... dunno if it is an problem of my pi, cause it is overload with other stuff. I rebootet and could´nt recreate again... but the interruption of my system still there and calms down when keep playing...

[OzGav]

As I mentioned in my first post a slight interruption as a player is joined is normal. https://music-assistant.io/faq/groups/#temporary-sync-group

[OzGav]

If you are experiencing the expected minor pause can we close this?

[OzGav]

Actually I’m going to keep this open as I’m advised that Sonos is one provider that should not have the pause. If you can provide more info about that or even a video recording with sound that would be great.

[hosh0815]

ScreenRecording_10-25-2024.17-32-15_1.mov

while this, the music interrupts (eg. @buro speaker) and kept playing somewhere else in the house I could hear, but not exactly which speaker... after a while doin nothing, it find itself again

have a look to lounge ;) I don´t know if you can see: I checked the lounge it unchecked itself

[marcelveldt]

I need to see the FULL log file, collected a few minutes after it showed this symptom.
Also note that you have a lot of devices. This will put a lot of strain on the network. Also, something I noticed in my own setup with Sonos speakers is that Sonos is updating their speakers the last couple of days and you can not join speakers of different versions.

[hosh0815]

music-assistant_today.log
this is the log from today... should be complete. yes, this is what I think is the most problem: many speaker... aaaand sonos :(