Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Firefox is opened with Internet Explorer homepage when the user launches directly Internet Explorer #2

Open
FrenchHope opened this issue Oct 24, 2019 · 8 comments

Comments

@FrenchHope
Copy link

When one click on Internet Explorer shortcut (no url as a parameter) Firefox is opened with internet explorer homepage passed as a parameter to Firefox. There should be en option to let the user launch Internet Explorer when no url is passed as a parameter to it.

@mkaply mkaply closed this as completed Oct 24, 2019
@mkaply mkaply reopened this Oct 24, 2019
@mkaply
Copy link
Collaborator

mkaply commented Oct 24, 2019

Did not mean to close this :)

@FrenchHope
Copy link
Author

That may seem counterintuitive but that would allow a future for Firefox in my company. Microsoft is adding Internet Explorer engine to their Chromium Edge which will satisfy most users (they usually dont care about ethics or personal data). Clicking on Internet Explorer (with a custom homepage) shortcut redirecting to Firefox is the kind of behavior that will prevent me to deploy the plugin since managers will consider it too restrictive.

@mkaply
Copy link
Collaborator

mkaply commented Oct 28, 2019

The design of the add-on (for Chrome and Firefox) is to specifically not use IE. So when you open IE, because it is navigating to a page that is supposed to be displayed in Firefox, it opens Firefox.

@FrenchHope
Copy link
Author

It is possible to force either firefox/chrome (with a "!" prefixing the URL) or Internet Explorer or allow both browsers with "." (all URLs except those specified) in the dedicated GPO parameter, but when one click on Internet Explorer shortcut it don't work even if the URL of the homepage (not in the URLs to open with one or another browser) should logically be comprised in the "."

I understand the design of the add-on but I find it a little paradoxical

@Dimas-sc
Copy link

I'm interested in this option too. I'd like to redirect and force some pages from Firefox to IE but not doing IE unusable, please consider add this option (like IEView addon did)

@mkaply
Copy link
Collaborator

mkaply commented Dec 4, 2019

I've thought about this more and I'm wondering, in your scenarios, do you want the user to come back from automatically at all?

What about disabling the IE plugin and then Firefox can send users to IE, but they have to manually switch back?

@Dimas-sc
Copy link

I've thought about this more and I'm wondering, in your scenarios, do you want the user to come back from automatically at all?

What about disabling the IE plugin and then Firefox can send users to IE, but they have to manually switch back?

In my case...

Best option: possibility to redirect Firefox to IE and IE to Firefox automatically but controlling which pages triggers the redirect in both sides.

Acceptable option: possibility to redirect Firefox to IE automatically and manual switch back to Firefox.
Is it possible to disable the IE plugin silently and automatically to all the users?

@mkaply
Copy link
Collaborator

mkaply commented Dec 10, 2019

Best option: possibility to redirect Firefox to IE and IE to Firefox automatically but controlling which pages triggers the redirect in both sides.

That's the way it should work today (Although there are some issues I'm looking at)

Is it possible to disable the IE plugin silently and automatically to all the users?

I don't know if Windows supports. I'm thinking about making separate install packages for just the messaging component.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

3 participants