diff --git a/lib/dotcom_web/live/schedule_finder_live.ex b/lib/dotcom_web/live/schedule_finder_live.ex
index 8df8bb8656..8d797a9619 100644
--- a/lib/dotcom_web/live/schedule_finder_live.ex
+++ b/lib/dotcom_web/live/schedule_finder_live.ex
@@ -72,6 +72,7 @@ defmodule DotcomWeb.ScheduleFinderLive do
           |> assign_new(:service_groups, fn -> service_groups end)
           |> assign_new(:loaded_trips, fn -> %{} end)
           |> assign_new(:selected_service_name, fn -> Map.get(selected_service, :label, "") end)
+          |> assign_new(:selected_service_key, fn -> service_key(selected_service) end)
           |> assign_new(:service_today?, fn ->
             Enum.any?(all_services, &(!is_nil(&1.now_date)))
           end)
@@ -131,6 +132,7 @@ defmodule DotcomWeb.ScheduleFinderLive do
           <.service_picker
             id={"service-picker-#{@route.id}"}
             selected_service_name={@selected_service_name}
+            selected_service_key={@selected_service_key}
             service_groups={@service_groups}
           />
           <.async_result :let={departures} assign={@departures}>
@@ -197,12 +199,11 @@ defmodule DotcomWeb.ScheduleFinderLive do
     end
   end
 
-  def handle_event("select_service", %{"selected_service" => selected_service_label}, socket) do
-    send(self(), %{selected_service: selected_service_label})
-
+  def handle_event("select_service", %{"selected_service" => selected_service_key}, socket) do
     {:noreply,
      socket
-     |> assign(:departures, AsyncResult.loading())}
+     |> assign_service(selected_service_key)
+     |> assign_departures()}
   end
 
   def handle_event(_, _, socket), do: {:noreply, socket}
@@ -227,13 +228,6 @@ defmodule DotcomWeb.ScheduleFinderLive do
     {:noreply, assign_alerts(socket)}
   end
 
-  def handle_info(%{selected_service: selected_service_label}, socket) do
-    {:noreply,
-     socket
-     |> assign_service(selected_service_label)
-     |> assign_departures()}
-  end
-
   def handle_info(_, socket), do: {:noreply, socket}
 
   defp subscribe_to_alerts(socket) do
@@ -320,20 +314,23 @@ defmodule DotcomWeb.ScheduleFinderLive do
     end
   end
 
-  defp assign_service(socket, selected_service_label) do
+  defp assign_service(socket, selected_service_key) do
     selected_dated_service =
       socket.assigns.service_groups
       |> Enum.flat_map(& &1.services)
-      |> Enum.find(&(&1.label == selected_service_label))
-
-    daily_schedule_date =
-      selected_dated_service.last_service_date
+      |> Enum.find(&(service_key(&1) == selected_service_key))
 
     socket
-    |> assign(:selected_service_name, selected_service_label)
-    |> assign(:daily_schedule_date, daily_schedule_date)
+    |> assign(:selected_service_name, selected_dated_service.label)
+    |> assign(:selected_service_key, selected_service_key)
+    |> assign(:daily_schedule_date, selected_dated_service.last_service_date)
   end
 
+  defp service_key(%{label: label, last_service_date: date}),
+    do: "#{Date.to_iso8601(date)}:#{label}"
+
+  defp service_key(_), do: ""
+
   defp get_departures(route_id, direction_id, stop_id, date) do
     case @schedule_finder.daily_departures(route_id, direction_id, stop_id, date) do
       {:ok, departures} -> {:ok, %{departures: departures}}
@@ -414,6 +411,7 @@ defmodule DotcomWeb.ScheduleFinderLive do
   attr :id, :string, required: true
   attr :service_groups, :list, required: true
   attr :selected_service_name, :string, default: ""
+  attr :selected_service_key, :string, default: ""
 
   defp service_picker(assigns) do
     ~H"""
@@ -426,13 +424,13 @@ defmodule DotcomWeb.ScheduleFinderLive do
       <label for={@id} class="sr-only">
         {~t(Choose a schedule type from the available options)}
       </label>
-      <select id={@id} class="mbta-input w-full" name="selected_service" phx-update="ignore">
+      <select id={@id} class="mbta-input w-full" name="selected_service">
         <%= for service_group <- @service_groups do %>
           <optgroup label={service_group.group_label}>
             <option
               :for={service <- service_group.services}
-              value={service.label}
-              selected={service.now_date || service.next_date}
+              value={service_key(service)}
+              selected={service_key(service) == @selected_service_key}
             >
               {service.label} {if(service.now_date, do: " (#{~t(Now)})")}
             </option>
diff --git a/test/dotcom_web/live/schedule_finder_live_test.exs b/test/dotcom_web/live/schedule_finder_live_test.exs
index 34882f63d0..3817c42781 100644
--- a/test/dotcom_web/live/schedule_finder_live_test.exs
+++ b/test/dotcom_web/live/schedule_finder_live_test.exs
@@ -277,6 +277,98 @@ defmodule DotcomWeb.ScheduleFinderLiveTest do
   end
 
   describe "Daily Departures" do
+    test "selects the requested schedule when service labels repeat across ratings", %{conn: conn} do
+      today = Dotcom.Utils.ServiceDateTime.service_date()
+      current_end_date = Date.shift(today, day: 7)
+      future_start_date = Date.shift(today, day: 14)
+      future_end_date = Date.shift(today, day: 21)
+
+      current_service =
+        Factories.Services.Service.build(:service,
+          start_date: Date.shift(today, day: -7),
+          end_date: current_end_date,
+          rating_start_date: Date.shift(today, day: -7),
+          rating_end_date: current_end_date,
+          rating_description: "Current",
+          type: :weekday,
+          typicality: :typical_service,
+          valid_days: [1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7]
+        )
+
+      future_service =
+        Factories.Services.Service.build(:service,
+          start_date: future_start_date,
+          end_date: future_end_date,
+          rating_start_date: future_start_date,
+          rating_end_date: future_end_date,
+          rating_description: "Future",
+          type: :weekday,
+          typicality: :typical_service,
+          valid_days: [1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7]
+        )
+
+      current_departure =
+        Factories.ScheduleFinder.build(:daily_departure, trip_id: "current-departure")
+
+      future_departure =
+        Factories.ScheduleFinder.build(:daily_departure, trip_id: "future-departure")
+
+      expect(Dotcom.ScheduleFinder.Mock, :daily_departures, 2, fn _, _, _, date ->
+        case date do
+          ^today -> {:ok, [current_departure]}
+          ^future_end_date -> {:ok, [future_departure]}
+        end
+      end)
+
+      route_id = FactoryHelpers.build(:id)
+      direction_id = FactoryHelpers.build(:direction_id)
+      stop_id = FactoryHelpers.build(:id)
+
+      assert {:ok, view, _html} =
+               visit_with_set_params(
+                 conn,
+                 route_id,
+                 direction_id,
+                 stop_id,
+                 [2],
+                 [current_service, future_service]
+               )
+
+      render_async(view)
+
+      current_service_key = "#{current_end_date}:Weekday schedules"
+      future_service_key = "#{future_end_date}:Weekday schedules"
+
+      assert has_element?(
+               view,
+               "[id='service-picker-#{route_id}'] option[value='#{current_service_key}'][selected]"
+             )
+
+      refute has_element?(
+               view,
+               "[id='service-picker-#{route_id}'] option[value='#{future_service_key}'][selected]"
+             )
+
+      loading_html =
+        view
+        |> form("#service-picker-form", selected_service: future_service_key)
+        |> render_change()
+
+      assert loading_html
+             |> Floki.parse_fragment!()
+             |> Floki.find("[data-test=\"departures_loading\"]") != []
+
+      render_async(view)
+
+      assert has_element?(
+               view,
+               "[id='service-picker-#{route_id}'] option[value='#{future_service_key}'][selected]"
+             )
+
+      assert has_element?(view, "[phx-value-trip='future-departure']")
+      refute has_element?(view, "[phx-value-trip='current-departure']")
+    end
+
     test "indicates no service", %{conn: conn} do
       expect(Services.Repo.Mock, :by_route_id, 2, fn _ -> [] end)
       expect(Dotcom.ScheduleFinder.Mock, :daily_departures, fn _, _, _, _ -> {:ok, []} end)
@@ -434,14 +526,15 @@ defmodule DotcomWeb.ScheduleFinderLiveTest do
          route_id,
          direction_id,
          stop_id,
-         route_types \\ [0, 1, 2, 3, 4]
+         route_types \\ [0, 1, 2, 3, 4],
+         services \\ nil
        ) do
     stub(Routes.Repo.Mock, :get, fn _ ->
       Factories.Routes.Route.build(:route, %{id: route_id, type: Faker.Util.pick(route_types)})
     end)
 
     stub(Services.Repo.Mock, :by_route_id, fn _ ->
-      Factories.Services.Service.build_list(15, :service)
+      services || Factories.Services.Service.build_list(15, :service)
     end)
 
     stub(Stops.Repo.Mock, :get, fn _ ->