Skip to content
This repository has been archived by the owner on Oct 5, 2023. It is now read-only.

[BUG] AI-generated text in saved story was different from what was saved #242

Open
Sporking opened this issue Feb 8, 2020 · 0 comments
Open

Comments

@Sporking
Copy link

Sporking commented Feb 8, 2020

On my iPhone, I had written a story which I was still working on. I had several pages worth of back-and-forth with the AI. I’m pretty sure I used the “/remember” feature a few times. The story seemed to be going in some interesting directions. I put it aside last night. Today, when I reentered AI Dungeon, I found myself at the initial list-of-five-options story prompt, so I went into “My Stories” and reopened the story I had been working on... except it wasn’t the same as when I had left it. All of the text I had typed was the same, but the text generated by the AI in response to each block of my text was often quite different, so much so that the story no longer made sense (since some of my responses had relied on elements introduced by the AI in its responses, but the new generated text was now not introducing these elements).

This is a bad bug. When a story gets saved, whether by deliberate user “save” action, by autosave when the app gets switched away from, or by the app getting restarted or crashing, the story should be saved exactly as it was, verbatim. There should be no regeneration of the AI’s responses. At all.

For one thing, the AI’s responses are a bit probabilistic: entering some text, using /revert, then entering the same text again often produces a different result. So there is no guarantee that the same sequence of entered user text blocks will yield the same responses from the AI if executed a second time. For another thing, the exact point in the sequence where a “/remember” prompt is issued often has effects on the text generated from that point forward.

Please modify all versions of AI Dungeon to save the entire text of a story exactly as the user last saw it, and to not ever try to regenerate the AI’s responses from the user’s entered text blocks.

@Sporking Sporking changed the title Saved story morphed AI-generated text in saved story was regenerated differently Feb 8, 2020
@Sporking Sporking changed the title AI-generated text in saved story was regenerated differently AI-generated text in saved story was different from what was saved Feb 8, 2020
@Sporking Sporking changed the title AI-generated text in saved story was different from what was saved [BUG] AI-generated text in saved story was different from what was saved Feb 8, 2020
Sign up for free to subscribe to this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in.
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

1 participant