Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

Sign up for GitHub

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Jump to bottom

[BUG] Shifter stopped working after Qdomyos #561

Open
Dekto opened this issue Aug 4, 2024 · 26 comments
Open

[BUG] Shifter stopped working after Qdomyos #561

Dekto opened this issue Aug 4, 2024 · 26 comments
Assignees
@eMadman

Comments

@Dekto
Copy link

Dekto commented Aug 4, 2024

Description

After using the Qdomyos Zwift app for automatic control during Peloton workouts on the Peloton Bike, the shifter no longer works.

Steps to reproduce

  1. Start Peloton Bike / Tablet
  2. Start SS2k
  3. Start Qdomyos Zwift App
  4. Start a Peloton Workout on the Bikes Tablet
  5. Confirm Popup on Qdomyos Zwift App
  6. Complete workout
  7. Close Qdomyos Zwift App

Expected behavior

The resistance should change via the shifter.

Actual behavior

When you tap the shifter button, the SS2k LED lights up but doesn't respond.

Additional Information

Peloton Bike
iPhone SE (2022) iOS 17.5.1
SS2k 24.4.28
Qdomyos Zwift 2.15.4
@Dekto Dekto changed the title [BUG] Sifter stopped working after Qdomyos [BUG] Shifter stopped working after Qdomyos Aug 4, 2024
@eMadman
Copy link
Collaborator

eMadman commented Aug 4, 2024

I'll try to reproduce this on my bike this weekend.

@eMadman eMadman self-assigned this Aug 4, 2024
@doudar
Copy link
Owner

doudar commented Aug 9, 2024

@cagnulein Can you send 0x01,0x1C (reboot) to the SS2k at the end of a session? That should resolve this issue. I'm guessing it's because of external control being used.

SmartSpin2k/src/BLE_Custom_Characteristic.cpp

Lines 535 to 542 in 69961f3

case BLE_reboot: // 0x1C
logBufLength += snprintf(logBuf + logBufLength, kLogBufCapacity - logBufLength, "<-reboot");
if (rxValue[0] == cc_write) {
ss2k->rebootFlag = true;
returnValue[0] = cc_success;
}
break;

@cagnulein
Copy link

yes sure, let me try to create a branch for this @Dekto @doudar

@cagnulein
Copy link

@doudar do I have to re initialize again the ss2k then? i mean with the watt, cadence and hr sync chars?

@doudar
Copy link
Owner

doudar commented Aug 9, 2024

At the start of a session, everything should be the same.

Maybe this is specific to Peloton workouts. What commands are you using for control on the Peloton workouts?

@cagnulein
Copy link

in order to answer you i need to understand if @Dekto is using SS2K in QZ like an ftms bike or like a ss2k device. I guess the first one (it has more sense indeed).

If it's so, i'm just sending FTMS_SET_TARGET_RESISTANCE_LEVEL command from 0 to 100

@doudar
Copy link
Owner

doudar commented Aug 9, 2024 •
edited
Loading

If that's the case, then you could probably just put it back into FTMS sim mode at the end of a session. Just send one slope command of 0% grade or something when the session is done.

@doudar
Copy link
Owner

doudar commented Aug 9, 2024

^^ Using the BLE FTMS Characteristic.

cagnulein added a commit to cagnulein/qdomyos-zwift that referenced this issue Aug 9, 2024
@cagnulein
Shifter stopped working after Qdomyos #561
24fe3c6 
doudar/SmartSpin2k#561
@cagnulein
Copy link

done @Dekto
send me an email to roberto.viola83 at gmail.com indicating this ticket and I will send you the new beta. Thanks

@Dekto
Copy link
Author

Dekto commented Aug 9, 2024

@cagnulein Hello, I use it as a SmartSpin2k device in the QZ app.

@cagnulein
Copy link

@Dekto
send me an email to roberto.viola83 at gmail.com indicating this ticket and I will send you the new beta. Thanks

@Dekto
Copy link
Author

Dekto commented Aug 10, 2024

@cagnulein

Hello, unfortunately the beta V2.16.67 does not fix the problem...

@doudar
Copy link
Owner

doudar commented Aug 10, 2024

@Dekto , thanks. @eMadman , can you get a log this weekend? Probably the most important is what it's saying when you try to shift.

@cagnulein
Copy link

cagnulein commented Aug 10, 2024 via email

@eMadman
Copy link
Collaborator

eMadman commented Aug 10, 2024

@cagnulein Entirely unrelated issue on my end - i'm having difficulty getting a connection to it at all. It seems to keep hanging on another device. I'm confident I have something wrong in my settings.

debug-Sat_Aug_10_13_18_37_2024.log

@Dekto
Copy link
Author

Dekto commented Aug 10, 2024

I could also upload my SmartSpin2k logs if I get information about where it is stored?

@cagnulein
Copy link

@cagnulein Entirely unrelated issue on my end - i'm having difficulty getting a connection to it at all. It seems to keep hanging on another device. I'm confident I have something wrong in my settings.

debug-Sat_Aug_10_13_18_37_2024.log

here i can see that qz is correctly connected to your ss2k. It's sending only resistance 25 and the other metrics are all 0. Is it intended?

@doudar
Copy link
Owner

doudar commented Aug 10, 2024

I could also upload my SmartSpin2k logs if I get information about where it is stored?

Follow these instructions, and if you can, use a pastebin.com url to post them here.

Thanks!

@Dekto
Copy link
Author

Dekto commented Aug 10, 2024

Ok, that's more complex than I thought. I'll try to figure it out in the next few days...

@eMadman
Copy link
Collaborator

eMadman commented Aug 12, 2024 •
edited by doudar
Loading

I figured out the QZ (connection) issue - it was my settings.

I was able to reproduce OP's issue.

QZ Log attached: debug-Sun_Aug_11_21_46_30_2024.log

SmartSpin2k log - this is the behavior on the device after quitting out of QZ

Start ride, end it. Stop ride in QZ, then quit the app.

	121883	[597319][E](BLE_Server): 30 00 00 00 89 03 00 00 99 8d 88 03 73 b6 -> 0x1818 | 0x2a63 | CPS(CPM)[ CD(0.00) PW(0) ]
	121884	[597320][E](BLE_Server): 03 89 03 00 00 99 8d 88 03 73 b6 -> 0x1816 | 0x2a5b | CSC(CSM)[ WheelRev(905) WheelTime(1470889984) CrankRev(1092688691) CrankTime(904) ]
	121885	[597327][E](BLE_Server): 64 02 00 00 00 00 23 00 00 00 00 -> 0x1826 | 0x2ad2 | FTMS(IBD)[ HR(0) CD(0.00) PW(0) SD(0.00) ]
	121886	[597747][E](BLE_Server): Client ID: 0 Address: 59:77:1c:fb:d8:fe Unsubscribed to 0x2a5b
	121887	[597748][E](BLE_Server): Client ID: 0 Address: 59:77:1c:fb:d8:fe Unsubscribed to 0x2a63
	121888	[597751][E](BLE_Server): Client ID: 0 Address: 59:77:1c:fb:d8:fe Unsubscribed to 0x2a37
	121889	[597751][E](BLE_Server): Client ID: 0 Address: 59:77:1c:fb:d8:fe Unsubscribed to 0x2ad9
	121890	[597754][E](BLE_Server): Client ID: 0 Address: 59:77:1c:fb:d8:fe Unsubscribed to 0x2ad2
	121891	[597754][E](BLE_Server): Bluetooth Remote Client Disconnected. Remaining Clients: 0
	121892	[598705][E](Custom_C): 01 17 <-shifterPosition
	121893	[599680][E](Custom_C): 01 17 <-shifterPosition
	121894	[600120][E](Custom_C): 01 17 <-shifterPosition
	121895	[600559][E](Custom_C): 01 17 <-shifterPosition
	121896	[601363][E](Custom_C): 01 17 <-shifterPosition
	121897	[601812][E](Custom_C): 01 17 <-shifterPosition
	121898	[602251][E](Custom_C): 01 17 <-shifterPosition
	121899	[603129][E](Custom_C): 01 17 <-shifterPosition
	121900	[603577][E](Custom_C): 01 17 <-shifterPosition
	121901	[604089][E](Custom_C): 01 17 <-shifterPosition
	121902	[605040][E](Custom_C): 01 17 <-shifterPosition
	121903	[605479][E](Custom_C): 01 17 <-shifterPosition
	121904	[605927][E](Custom_C): 01 17 <-shifterPosition
	121905	[606878][E](Custom_C): 01 17 <-shifterPosition
	121906	[607317][E](Custom_C): 01 17 <-shifterPosition
	121907	[607982][E](Custom_C): 01 17 <-shifterPosition
	121908	[608567][E](Custom_C): 01 17 <-shifterPosition
	121909	[609006][E](Custom_C): 01 17 <-shifterPosition

@doudar
Copy link
Owner

doudar commented Aug 12, 2024 •
edited
Loading

@eMadman

What mode was the SS2k in before the disconnect?

@cagnulein
Copy link

qz, when acts as a ftms bike as @eMadman settings, it doesn't read anything. it just uses the notifications, so it sounds very strange. maybe SS2K accepts 2 connections on bluetooth and it's connected to something else?

@eMadman
Copy link
Collaborator

eMadman commented Aug 13, 2024

qz, when acts as a ftms bike as @eMadman settings, it doesn't read anything. it just uses the notifications, so it sounds very strange. maybe SS2K accepts 2 connections on bluetooth and it's connected to something else?

Hmm. There should be no other connection to the smartspin.

Last night, the only way I got it to connect to the SmartSpin2k was to have it as an FTMS bike. DIsabling that setting today, it seems to get a connection. I'll capture a new log

@eMadman
Copy link
Collaborator

eMadman commented Aug 13, 2024 •
edited
Loading

Steps taken this time. Motor doesn't turn when expected after the peloton ride.

QZ Log: debug-Mon_Aug_12_21_37_23_2024.log
SS2K Log: Custom UDP Receiver (Port 10000).txt

  • Start SmartSpin2k and QZ

  • Start Peloton ride

  • End ride

  • Quit app

  • Press physical shifters up/down (421797)

  • Try web shifter (138341)

  • Relaunch QZ - new log file: debug-Mon_Aug_12_21_44_42_2024.log

  • Try to shift in Ss2k app (139919 I think)

  • Try to change resistance in QZ

@cagnulein
Copy link

@eMadman ftms bike setting disabled or not doesn't change anything since you have the peloton ss2k setting enabled. so i guess it was something else.

qz in the log here just writes these as expected

Mon. Aug. 12 21:39:15 2024 1723513155133 Debug: ../src/devices/bluetooth.cpp void bluetooth::debug(const QString &) " >> 00 // requestControl" Mon. Aug. 12 21:39:15 2024 1723513155451 Debug: ../src/devices/bluetooth.cpp void bluetooth::debug(const QString &) " >> 07 // start simulation" Mon. Aug. 12 21:39:15 2024 1723513155839 Debug: ../src/devices/bluetooth.cpp void bluetooth::debug(const QString &) " >> 04 19 // forceResistance 25" Mon. Aug. 12 21:39:59 2024 1723513199607 Debug: ../src/devices/bluetooth.cpp void bluetooth::debug(const QString &) " >> 04 1b // forceResistance 27" Mon. Aug. 12 21:40:30 2024 1723513230488 Debug: ../src/devices/bluetooth.cpp void bluetooth::debug(const QString &) " >> 04 1d // forceResistance 29" Mon. Aug. 12 21:43:12 2024 1723513392334 Debug: ../src/devices/bluetooth.cpp void bluetooth::debug(const QString &) " >> 04 2d // forceResistance 45"

@doudar did you get something from the ss2k log?

@Dekto Dekto mentioned this issue Sep 20, 2024
Closed
@doudar
Copy link
Owner

doudar commented Nov 10, 2024

I'd appreciate another test. #591 should fix this.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Assignees

@eMadman eMadman

Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Milestone
No milestone
Development

No branches or pull requests
4 participants
@cagnulein @doudar @eMadman @Dekto