Spec [ postgresql-apb ] failed validation for the following reason: [ APB Spec version [1.0.0] out of bounds 1.0 <= 1.0 ]

[jmontleon]

With the latest image of ASB / OAB Broker deployed on origin 3.10 using command "oc cluster add automation-service-broker", we can't use anymore some services such as postgresql-apb as there is a spec validation error

time="2018-09-11T09:14:08Z" level=warning
msg="Spec [ postgresql-apb ] failed validation for the following reason: 
[ APB Spec version [1.0.0] out of bounds 1.0 <= 1.0 ]. 
It will not be made available."

Broker log : https://gist.github.com/cmoulliard/789b36c015f927f66a8ec4d1c58400d0#file-gistfile1-txt-L379

[jmontleon]

@cmoulliard

[jmontleon]

The APB specs for these APB's were updated to go along with:
automationbroker/bundle-lib@78e6a94

We either need to set them to 1.0 to be reverse compatible or bring this change into the release-1.2/3.10 broker to fix this. It does not look like bundle-lib was forked for 1.2 from what I can see, unless this was the intention of the release-0.1 branch?

@dzager @shawn-hurley @eriknelson @jmrodi How would you like to handle this? It might be easiest to set the version on the APB's to 1.0 if there's no reason to bump the version beyond 1.0/1.0.0?

[cmoulliard]

This is really blocking for us as we can't continue to develop our devtools, guides, .... Is there a workaround when we use oc cluster up and origin 3.10 ?

[geoand]

A workaround would be greatly appreciated :)

[jmontleon]

I created this on the wrong repo myself; sorry should have been openshift/ansible-service-broker. Haven't had enough coffee yet. I'll leave it here for now so we can walk through it

[leifmadsen]

I've seen this same thing on a handful of APBs being importing into OpenShift 3.9 as well.

[2018-09-11T15:03:06.28Z] [INFO] - Validating specs...
[2018-09-11T15:03:06.281Z] [WARNING] - Spec [ mysql-apb ] failed validation for the following reason: [ APB Spec version [1.0.0] out of bounds 1.0 <= 1.0 ]. It will not be made available.
[2018-09-11T15:03:06.281Z] [WARNING] - Spec [ postgresql-apb ] failed validation for the following reason: [ APB Spec version [1.0.0] out of bounds 1.0 <= 1.0 ]. It will not be made available.
[2018-09-11T15:03:06.281Z] [WARNING] - Spec [ mediawiki-apb ] failed validation for the following reason: [ APB Spec version [1.0.0] out of bounds 1.0 <= 1.0 ]. It will not be made available.
[2018-09-11T15:03:06.281Z] [WARNING] - Spec [ mariadb-apb ] failed validation for the following reason: [ APB Spec version [1.0.0] out of bounds 1.0 <= 1.0 ]. It will not be made available.
[2018-09-11T15:03:06.281Z] [WARNING] - 4 specs of 43 discovered specs failed validation from registry: docker.io

[Asgoret]

yeah.... OKD 3.11 same thing... is there any help from RH or developers of this broker? everywhere is old guides or examples...and in ansible-galaxy 60%+ of examples are broken(((

[djzager]

yeah.... OKD 3.11 same thing... is there any help from RH or developers of this broker? everywhere is old guides or examples...and in ansible-galaxy 60%+ of examples are broken(((

I'm sorry that this is causing you trouble. It would help me if you expanded on this "everywhere is old guides or examples". The examples, particular postgresql-apb, mariadb-apb, mediawiki-apb, and mysql-apb have been updated and these should also be what you see in ansible-galaxy. The specific problem here is that older brokers (v3.9 and v3.10) are being pointed at new APBs (latest). I suspect that even in the case of OKD 3.11 if you are using the automation-broker component you are getting the v3.10 version of the broker that is not compatible with latest APBs.

I'm curious, in this case, how you are deploying the broker? Is it via oc?

[Asgoret]

yeah.... OKD 3.11 same thing... is there any help from RH or developers of this broker? everywhere is old guides or examples...and in ansible-galaxy 60%+ of examples are broken(((

I'm sorry that this is causing you trouble. It would help me if you expanded on this "everywhere is old guides or examples". The examples, particular postgresql-apb, mariadb-apb, mediawiki-apb, and mysql-apb have been updated and these should also be what you see in ansible-galaxy. The specific problem here is that older brokers (v3.9 and v3.10) are being pointed at new APBs (latest). I suspect that even in the case of OKD 3.11 if you are using the automation-broker component you are getting the v3.10 version of the broker that is not compatible with latest APBs.

I'm curious, in this case, how you are deploying the broker? Is it via oc?
Hi! Thanks for quick response.

In my keys i have folder dev and APB scan it for version. When i delete it it works fine) At this moment i seach information how to write more complicated playbooks with different plans and environment.

I use minishift, so the APB component is latest (i think). When i talk about documentation i mean OKD docks. They still start from apb init and there is no links to github with new documentation. Also when you instal APB component you get a lot of APB examples (like prometheus and etc) and they didn't work. I mean DB is simple examples and something with GUI, different plans is more instesresting for learning and this examples doesn't work...