Should the setting be global? or trakt and plex should have own option?

As far as I know, Trakt automatically removes watched items from watchlist.

From trakt.tv :

Once you watch an item from your watchlist, it automatically gets removed.

That doesn't really give answer.

As you can still put items to trakt playlist if the item is watched. trakt only removes when scrobble ends or you add watch date. so you could still use plextraktsync to sync over. I suppose their use case would be that you want to rewatch.

so the flag would make sense for sync.plex_to_trakt as well

also, there's trakt lists, this option would only be effect on watchlist, not trakt lists? if trakt/plex lists it probably should be configurable per list.

I don't understand how the rewatch usecase needs PTS to remove an item from trakt watchlist.

I mean pts can add item back to trakt watchlist if it's present in plex watchlist. in response to your statement:

• Feature request: Add optional config setting to remove watched items from watchlists #1494 (comment)

I mean pts can add item back to trakt watchlist if it's present in plex watchlist. in response to your statement:

* [Feature request: Add optional config setting to remove watched items from watchlists #1494 (comment)](https://github.com/Taxel/PlexTraktSync/issues/1494#issuecomment-1894120548)

No, pts will not add it back because it will be already removed from Plex watchlist with the setting remove_watched_from_watchlist. If you disagree, can you show detailed usecase step by step.

you are talking about the future. but I'm speaking of current behavior and when remove_watched_from_watchlist = false.

pointless discussion. all I wanted to say that your statement is not answering the question should it be global or plex only option. because you can add watched item in trakt watchlist.

Usecases are important. No need to code things for impossible usecase.

it's simple usecase: keep trakt watchlist synced with plex watchlist, like it's now. whether it's practical, is other question. but since the request here is to make it configurable, it's practical for someone.

After I watch a movie on plex I go to remove it from watchlist + remove it from watchlist from trakt.
With this functionality trakt would remove it automatically after i watch it from both lists, so nothing for me to do.
2 manual actions vs no manual action.
+1 for this feature :)

That's precisely the scenario I explained.
Once watched, trakt automatically removes it from Trakt watchlist.
PTS only have to remove it from Plex watchlist.

and I explained that you can use pts to sync the status back.

Any news on this?

For me the usecase would be:
Using a trakt liked playlist. So if I watch an episode in plex it will not being removed from trakt playlist because I do not own this playlist.
So it would be very nice, if this episode would then be removed from the plex playlist

watched lists are always yours, what you probably have in mind is liked lists, their behaviour is somewhat different anyway. this issue is about watch list syncing.

Okay, should I open an additional feature request for this?

@Bart1909 if you want the feature then yes, you should describe what you want.