Everything stops working when I disable main domain/www Proxy Host

[Airfirewall]

Using Nginx Proxy Manager v2.11.2 and cloudflared 2024.6.1

So I don't use www.example.com much anymore and went to disable it but everything stopped working and shows cloudflared cannot connect to respond to nginx proxy manager.

so if I have this everything works but if I disable example.com www.example.com everything stops working.
example.com www.example.com---Enabled
auth.example.com-------------------Enabled
homepage.example.com------------Enabled
overseerr.example.com--------------Enabled

Why would this stop everything from working? when I re-enable the main domain everything works again.
example.com www.example.com---Disabled
auth.example.com-------------------Enabled
homepage.example.com------------Enabled
overseerr.example.com--------------Enabled

Cloudflare config

ingress:

• hostname: "*.example.com"
  service: https://10.10.0.10:18443
  originRequest:
  originServerName: "example.com"
• service: http_status:404\

Cloudflared error

2024-06-30T18:31:31Z ERR error="Unable to reach the origin service. The service may be down or it may not be responding to traffic from cloudflared: remote error: tls: unrecognized name" connIndex=0 event=1 ingressRule=0 originService=https://10.10.0.10:18443
2024-06-30T18:31:31Z ERR Request failed error="Unable to reach the origin service. The service may be down or it may not be responding to traffic from cloudflared: remote error: tls: unrecognized name" connIndex=0 dest=https://overseerr.example.com/login event=0 ip=###.###.###.### type=http

[Airfirewall]

added example.com into 404 hosts and left the www.example.com disabled in proxy and everything works. Just confused why removing example.com would cause everything to stop working